Related questions
Question
- According to the document, why do Hideyoshi and the Tokugawas want to suppress Christianity? How are Christians depicted?
- List some of the early minor restrictions on Christians and then some of the later major restrictions issued against Christians?
- Was Emperor Hideyoshi objecting to Christianity, Christians themselves, or just a perceived threat from the West as a whole?
![17. Ships arriving in Hirado must sell their raw silk at the price set in Nagasaki, and are not permitted to engage in
business transactions until after the price is established in Nagaski.
pale or washed out, but rather the freshness and beauty of their features well indicated their fate. Now they were set up near
a large pole, from the top of which hung the Tyrant's proclamation. Not faraway they espied a house wherein the corpses
had been buried and cairns of immense stones had been set up over them; thus if at any time the Japanese should be silent
about these men, the very stones would speak.
You are hereby required to act in accordance with the provisions set above.
It is so ordered.
Kaga no-kami Masamori et al., seals. To: Sakakibara
Hida no-kami, Sengoku Yamoto no-kami
Inscribed on a pole which emerged from the midst of these stones was the name of the legation and the reason for
the executions; it was indeed their monument for posterity and an everlasting trophy of their glory. With unfeeling barbarity
the Tyrant had added this inscription: A similar penalty will be suffered by all those who henceforward come to these shores
from Portugal, whether they be sailors, whether they come by error or whether they be driven higher by storm. Even more,
if the King of Portugal, or Shaka, or even the GOD of the Christians were to come, they would all pay the very same penalty.
COMPLETION OF THE EXCLUSION, 1639
The matter relating to the proscription of Christianity is known [ to the Portuguese]. However, heretofore they have
secretly transported those who are going to propagate that religion.
2. If those who believe in that religion band together in an attempt to do evil things, they must be subjected to punishment.
3. While those who believe in the preaching of padres are in hiding, there are incidents in which that country (Portugal)
has sent gifts to them for their sustenance.
1.
Questions:
1) According to the document, why do Hideyoshi and the Tokugawas want to suppress
In view of the above, hereafter entry by the Portuguese galeota is forbidden. If they insist on coming [to Japan], the ships
must be destroyed and anyone aboard those ships must be beheaded. We have received the above order and are thus
transmitting it to you accordingly.
Christianity? How are Christians depicted?
The above concerns our disposition with regard to the galeota.
2) List some of the early minor restrictions on Christians and then some of the later major
restrictions issued against Christians?
Memorandum
With regard to those who believe
Christianity, you are aware that there is a proscription, and thus knowing, you are not
3) Was Emperor Hideyoshi objecting to Christianity, Christians themselves, or just a
perceived threat from the West as a whole?
permitted to let padres and those who believe in their preaching to come aboard your ships. If there is any violation, all of
you who are aboard will be considered culpable. If there is anyone who hides the fact that he is a Christian and boards your
ship, you may report it to us. A substantial reward will be given to you for this information.
This memorandum is to be given to those who come on Chinese ships. (A similar note to the Dutch ships.)
The Fate of the Embassy from Macao, 1640 by Antonio Cardim, S.J.
Because many serious crimes have been committed over a number of years by the propagation of the Christian religion in
defiance of his decree, the shogun last year forbade under grave penalties all voyages from Macao to Japan, laying down
that if any ship were to come to Japan despite this prohibition, the vessel would be burnt and the sailors and merchants
executed. This edict was promulgated both summarily and in detail. Nevertheless, these men have blatantly violated the
aforesaid decree by their voyage and are seriously at fault. Furthermore, in spite of their assertion that on no account will
they send hereafter ministers of the Christian religion to Japan, the ambassadorial letters from Macao are silent on this point.
Since, therefore, the shogu'n has prohibited such voyages on account of the Christian religion and since no mention of this
matter is made in these letters, it is quite evident that the entire legation is but a pretence. For this reason, all who have come
hither in this ship are to pay the extreme penalty.
It has accordingly been decided that the ship shall be consumed by flames and that the principal ambassadors shall
be put to death along with their companions so that nothing may remain of this harbinger of evil. Thus the example which
the shogu'n has made of them wil1 be noticed abroad in Macao and the home country; as a consequence, all will learn to
respect the rights of Princes and Kings. We nevertheless desire that the rabble among the crew be spared and sent back
to Macao. But should any other ship come hither by force of adverse circumstances
it be known that, in whatsoever port it may call, one and all will be put to death.
for any other reason what- soever, let
Given on the 3rd day of the 6th moon of the 17th year of the Kanei era, that is, the 25th day of July in the year
1640.
At the same time they also asked what they would say about this punishment to foreign peoples in the Orient and
even in Europe, if by chance they should go tither. They replied that they would tell the truth; to wit, that the shogun of
Japan had put the Portuguese ambassadors to death and had set fire to their ship because they professed the Christian religion
and had disobeyed his edict, and that they, to the number of thirteen, had been spared this punishment and sent back so that
they could recount what had happened; but they added that the kings and all the peoples of the world would most certainly
condemn what had been done as a crime against international law.
They were then taken thence to the mount of execution in order to identify the heads of the executed men, which
they found affixed to boards in three groups. The heads of the ambassadors were set apart from the rest; they did not appear](https://content.bartleby.com/qna-images/question/599ebb4c-dd94-407b-85f3-8fbd3e217ad7/1f35bbcc-0c40-4f4e-9c8e-4a789ed3893e/fzgwjvn_processed.png)
Transcribed Image Text:17. Ships arriving in Hirado must sell their raw silk at the price set in Nagasaki, and are not permitted to engage in
business transactions until after the price is established in Nagaski.
pale or washed out, but rather the freshness and beauty of their features well indicated their fate. Now they were set up near
a large pole, from the top of which hung the Tyrant's proclamation. Not faraway they espied a house wherein the corpses
had been buried and cairns of immense stones had been set up over them; thus if at any time the Japanese should be silent
about these men, the very stones would speak.
You are hereby required to act in accordance with the provisions set above.
It is so ordered.
Kaga no-kami Masamori et al., seals. To: Sakakibara
Hida no-kami, Sengoku Yamoto no-kami
Inscribed on a pole which emerged from the midst of these stones was the name of the legation and the reason for
the executions; it was indeed their monument for posterity and an everlasting trophy of their glory. With unfeeling barbarity
the Tyrant had added this inscription: A similar penalty will be suffered by all those who henceforward come to these shores
from Portugal, whether they be sailors, whether they come by error or whether they be driven higher by storm. Even more,
if the King of Portugal, or Shaka, or even the GOD of the Christians were to come, they would all pay the very same penalty.
COMPLETION OF THE EXCLUSION, 1639
The matter relating to the proscription of Christianity is known [ to the Portuguese]. However, heretofore they have
secretly transported those who are going to propagate that religion.
2. If those who believe in that religion band together in an attempt to do evil things, they must be subjected to punishment.
3. While those who believe in the preaching of padres are in hiding, there are incidents in which that country (Portugal)
has sent gifts to them for their sustenance.
1.
Questions:
1) According to the document, why do Hideyoshi and the Tokugawas want to suppress
In view of the above, hereafter entry by the Portuguese galeota is forbidden. If they insist on coming [to Japan], the ships
must be destroyed and anyone aboard those ships must be beheaded. We have received the above order and are thus
transmitting it to you accordingly.
Christianity? How are Christians depicted?
The above concerns our disposition with regard to the galeota.
2) List some of the early minor restrictions on Christians and then some of the later major
restrictions issued against Christians?
Memorandum
With regard to those who believe
Christianity, you are aware that there is a proscription, and thus knowing, you are not
3) Was Emperor Hideyoshi objecting to Christianity, Christians themselves, or just a
perceived threat from the West as a whole?
permitted to let padres and those who believe in their preaching to come aboard your ships. If there is any violation, all of
you who are aboard will be considered culpable. If there is anyone who hides the fact that he is a Christian and boards your
ship, you may report it to us. A substantial reward will be given to you for this information.
This memorandum is to be given to those who come on Chinese ships. (A similar note to the Dutch ships.)
The Fate of the Embassy from Macao, 1640 by Antonio Cardim, S.J.
Because many serious crimes have been committed over a number of years by the propagation of the Christian religion in
defiance of his decree, the shogun last year forbade under grave penalties all voyages from Macao to Japan, laying down
that if any ship were to come to Japan despite this prohibition, the vessel would be burnt and the sailors and merchants
executed. This edict was promulgated both summarily and in detail. Nevertheless, these men have blatantly violated the
aforesaid decree by their voyage and are seriously at fault. Furthermore, in spite of their assertion that on no account will
they send hereafter ministers of the Christian religion to Japan, the ambassadorial letters from Macao are silent on this point.
Since, therefore, the shogu'n has prohibited such voyages on account of the Christian religion and since no mention of this
matter is made in these letters, it is quite evident that the entire legation is but a pretence. For this reason, all who have come
hither in this ship are to pay the extreme penalty.
It has accordingly been decided that the ship shall be consumed by flames and that the principal ambassadors shall
be put to death along with their companions so that nothing may remain of this harbinger of evil. Thus the example which
the shogu'n has made of them wil1 be noticed abroad in Macao and the home country; as a consequence, all will learn to
respect the rights of Princes and Kings. We nevertheless desire that the rabble among the crew be spared and sent back
to Macao. But should any other ship come hither by force of adverse circumstances
it be known that, in whatsoever port it may call, one and all will be put to death.
for any other reason what- soever, let
Given on the 3rd day of the 6th moon of the 17th year of the Kanei era, that is, the 25th day of July in the year
1640.
At the same time they also asked what they would say about this punishment to foreign peoples in the Orient and
even in Europe, if by chance they should go tither. They replied that they would tell the truth; to wit, that the shogun of
Japan had put the Portuguese ambassadors to death and had set fire to their ship because they professed the Christian religion
and had disobeyed his edict, and that they, to the number of thirteen, had been spared this punishment and sent back so that
they could recount what had happened; but they added that the kings and all the peoples of the world would most certainly
condemn what had been done as a crime against international law.
They were then taken thence to the mount of execution in order to identify the heads of the executed men, which
they found affixed to boards in three groups. The heads of the ambassadors were set apart from the rest; they did not appear
![2.
The [missionaries] approach people in provinces and districts to make them their followers, and let them destroy
Japan Encounters the West
shrines and temples. This is an unheard of outrage. When a vassal receives a province, a district, a village or another
form of a fief, he must consider it as a property entrusted to him on a temporary basis. He must follow the laws of this
The Portuguese reached Japan in 1543. The Japanese were curious and eager to interact with the Westerners
at first. Japanese ships already dominated an active Asian trade network centered on the East China Sea and
began vigorous interaction with Portuguese, Spanish, and Dutch merchants. Along with the merchants came
Christian missionaries. Japan has a long history of intellectual and religious open- ness. In addition to native
Shinto beliefs, various forms of Buddhism were well established in Japan and Confucian philosophy was
influential among the educated. Christianity became very popular in the western regions of Japan in the century
after contact with the West.
country, and abide by their intent. However, some vassals illegally [commend part of their fiefs to the church]. This
is a culpable offense.
3. The padres, by their special knowledge [in the sciences and medicine], feel that they can at will entice people to become
their believers
In so doing they commit the illegal act of destroying the teachings of Buddha prevailing in Japan. These
padres cannot be permitted to remain in Japan. They must prepare to leave the country within twenty days of the
issuance of this notice. However, the vassals must not make unreasonable demands on the padres, which shall be
treated as a culpable offense.
By 1638, however, missionaries had been expelled, foreign merchants were virtually banned, and Japan- ese
were prohibited from leaving. There are several reasons for this abrupt turn of events. First, Euro- pean explorers
arrived in Japan during a time of civil war among powerful landlords called daimyo. Over time, Europeans were
seen as supporting certain factions in return for the opportunity to spread
Christianity in territories of those daimyo. Once Japan was unified by Toyotomi Hideyoshi and his successors,
the Tokugawas, Europeans influence became even more suspect. Japanese Christians were suspected of
having loyalties to religious leaders outside Japan. After the Spanish conquered the Philippines, the Tokugawas
worried that European merchants and missionaries were merely the van- guard of a conquering force. Finally,
the new regime desired a monopoly on international trade. First missionaries were expelled, then Christianity
was suppressed, and eventually all contact with the West was broken off, with the exception of one Dutch
merchant vessel a year.
The black [Portuguese and Spanish] ships come to Japan to engage in trade. Thus the matter is a separate one. They
can continue to engage in trade.
Hereafter, anyone who does not hinder the teachings of Buddha, whether he be a merchant or not, may come and go
freely from Christian countries to Japan.
5.
This is our wish, and so ordered Fifteenth year of
Tensho [1587], sixth month, 19th day.
THE EDICT OF 1635 ORDERING THE CLOSING OF JAPAN: ADDRESSED TO THE JOINT BUGYO OF
NAGASAKI
The first two documents. From, 1587, show the growing suspicion of Christian missionaries by Hideyoshi. At this
point, Europeans are still allowed to trade, but not spread their religion. The second set of documents date from
1638 to 1640 and represent the final stages of the Closing of Japan, including the killing of Portuguese envoys
from Macao, a trading colony on the south China coast.
1.
Japanese ships are strictly forbidden to leave for foreign countries.
No Japanese is permitted to go abroad. If there is anyone who attempts to do so secretly, he must be executed. The
2.
ship so involved must be impounded and its owner arrested, and the matter must be reported to the higher authority.
If any Japanese returns from overseas after residing there, he must be put to death.
3.
Source: John David Lu, Sources of Japanese History, vol. II, (McGraw-Hill) rights reverted to author.
4.
there
s any place where the teachings of padres (Christianity) is practiced, the two of you must order a thorough
investigation.
5.
Any informer revealing the whereabouts of the followers of padres (Christians) must be rewarded accordingly. If
LIMITATION ON THE PROPAGATION OF CHRISTIANITY, 1587
anyone reveals the whereabouts of a high ranking padre, he must be given one hundred pieces of silver. For those
1. Whether one desires to become a follower of the padre is up to that person's own conscience.
2. If one receives a province, a district, or a village as his fief, and forces farmers in his domain who are properly
registered under certain temples to become followers of the padre against their wishes, then he has committed a most
unreasonable illegal act.
of lower ranks, depending on the deed, the reward must be set accordingly.
If a foreign ship has an objection [to the measures adopted] and it becomes necessary to report the matter to Edo, you
may ask the Omura domain to provide ships to guard the foreign ship, as was done previously.
If there are any Southern Barbarians (Westerners) who propagate the teachings of padres, or otherwise commit
crimes, they may be incarcerated in the prison maintained by the Omura domain, as was done previously.
All incoming ships must be carefully searched for the followers of padres.
No single trading city [see 12 below] shall be permitted to purchase all the merchandise brought by foreign ships.
10. Samurai are not permitted to purchase any goods originating from foreign ships directly from Chinese merchants in
6.
7.
8.
When a vassal (kyu nin) receives a grant of a province or a district, he must consider it as a property entrusted to him
on a temporary basis. A vassal may be moved from one place to another, but farmers remain in the same place. Thus
if an unreasonable illegal act is committed [as described above], the vassal will be called upon to account for his
culpable offense. The intent of this provision must be observed.
3.
9.
Nagasaki.
11.
After a list of merchandise brought by foreign ships is sent to Edo, as before you may order that commercial dealings
4. Anyone whose fief is over 200 cho and who can expect two to three thousand kan of rice harvest each year must
may take place without waiting for a reply from Edo.
12.
After settling the price, all white yarns (raw silk) brought by foreign ships shall be allocated to the five trading cities
and other quarters as stipulated.
After settling the price of white yarns (raw silk), other merchandise [brought by foreign ships] may be traded freely
between the [licensed] dealers. However, in view of the fact that Chinese ships are small and cannot bring large
consignments, you may issue orders of sale at your discretion. Additionally, payment for the goods purchased must
be made within twenty days after the price is set.
receive permission from the authorities before becoming a follower of the padre.
Anyone whose fief is smaller than the one described above may, as his conscience dictates, select for himself from
between eight and nine religions.
5.
13.
8.
If a daimyo who has a fief over a province, a district or a village, forces his retainers to become followers of the
padre, he is committing a crime worse than the followers of Honganji who assembled in their temple [to engage in the
14.
Ikko rio t). This will have an adverse effect on [the welfare of] the nation. Anyone who cannot use good judgment in
The date of departure homeward of foreign ships shall not be later than the twentieth day of the ninth month. Any
ships arriving in Japan later than usual shall depart within fifty days of their arrival. As to the departure of Chinese
this matter wil1 be punished.
ships, you may use your discretion to order their departure after the departure of the Portuguese galeota (galleon).
15. The goods brought by foreign ships which remained unsold may not be deposited or accepted from deposit.
16. The arrival in Nagaski of representatives of the five trading cities shall not be later that the fifth day of the seventh
month. Anyone arriving later than that date shall lose the quota assigned to his city.
EXPULSION OF MISSIONARIES, 1587
1
Japan is the country of gods, but has been receiving false teachings from Christian countries. This cannot be tolerated
any further.](https://content.bartleby.com/qna-images/question/599ebb4c-dd94-407b-85f3-8fbd3e217ad7/1f35bbcc-0c40-4f4e-9c8e-4a789ed3893e/dywgdro_processed.png)
Transcribed Image Text:2.
The [missionaries] approach people in provinces and districts to make them their followers, and let them destroy
Japan Encounters the West
shrines and temples. This is an unheard of outrage. When a vassal receives a province, a district, a village or another
form of a fief, he must consider it as a property entrusted to him on a temporary basis. He must follow the laws of this
The Portuguese reached Japan in 1543. The Japanese were curious and eager to interact with the Westerners
at first. Japanese ships already dominated an active Asian trade network centered on the East China Sea and
began vigorous interaction with Portuguese, Spanish, and Dutch merchants. Along with the merchants came
Christian missionaries. Japan has a long history of intellectual and religious open- ness. In addition to native
Shinto beliefs, various forms of Buddhism were well established in Japan and Confucian philosophy was
influential among the educated. Christianity became very popular in the western regions of Japan in the century
after contact with the West.
country, and abide by their intent. However, some vassals illegally [commend part of their fiefs to the church]. This
is a culpable offense.
3. The padres, by their special knowledge [in the sciences and medicine], feel that they can at will entice people to become
their believers
In so doing they commit the illegal act of destroying the teachings of Buddha prevailing in Japan. These
padres cannot be permitted to remain in Japan. They must prepare to leave the country within twenty days of the
issuance of this notice. However, the vassals must not make unreasonable demands on the padres, which shall be
treated as a culpable offense.
By 1638, however, missionaries had been expelled, foreign merchants were virtually banned, and Japan- ese
were prohibited from leaving. There are several reasons for this abrupt turn of events. First, Euro- pean explorers
arrived in Japan during a time of civil war among powerful landlords called daimyo. Over time, Europeans were
seen as supporting certain factions in return for the opportunity to spread
Christianity in territories of those daimyo. Once Japan was unified by Toyotomi Hideyoshi and his successors,
the Tokugawas, Europeans influence became even more suspect. Japanese Christians were suspected of
having loyalties to religious leaders outside Japan. After the Spanish conquered the Philippines, the Tokugawas
worried that European merchants and missionaries were merely the van- guard of a conquering force. Finally,
the new regime desired a monopoly on international trade. First missionaries were expelled, then Christianity
was suppressed, and eventually all contact with the West was broken off, with the exception of one Dutch
merchant vessel a year.
The black [Portuguese and Spanish] ships come to Japan to engage in trade. Thus the matter is a separate one. They
can continue to engage in trade.
Hereafter, anyone who does not hinder the teachings of Buddha, whether he be a merchant or not, may come and go
freely from Christian countries to Japan.
5.
This is our wish, and so ordered Fifteenth year of
Tensho [1587], sixth month, 19th day.
THE EDICT OF 1635 ORDERING THE CLOSING OF JAPAN: ADDRESSED TO THE JOINT BUGYO OF
NAGASAKI
The first two documents. From, 1587, show the growing suspicion of Christian missionaries by Hideyoshi. At this
point, Europeans are still allowed to trade, but not spread their religion. The second set of documents date from
1638 to 1640 and represent the final stages of the Closing of Japan, including the killing of Portuguese envoys
from Macao, a trading colony on the south China coast.
1.
Japanese ships are strictly forbidden to leave for foreign countries.
No Japanese is permitted to go abroad. If there is anyone who attempts to do so secretly, he must be executed. The
2.
ship so involved must be impounded and its owner arrested, and the matter must be reported to the higher authority.
If any Japanese returns from overseas after residing there, he must be put to death.
3.
Source: John David Lu, Sources of Japanese History, vol. II, (McGraw-Hill) rights reverted to author.
4.
there
s any place where the teachings of padres (Christianity) is practiced, the two of you must order a thorough
investigation.
5.
Any informer revealing the whereabouts of the followers of padres (Christians) must be rewarded accordingly. If
LIMITATION ON THE PROPAGATION OF CHRISTIANITY, 1587
anyone reveals the whereabouts of a high ranking padre, he must be given one hundred pieces of silver. For those
1. Whether one desires to become a follower of the padre is up to that person's own conscience.
2. If one receives a province, a district, or a village as his fief, and forces farmers in his domain who are properly
registered under certain temples to become followers of the padre against their wishes, then he has committed a most
unreasonable illegal act.
of lower ranks, depending on the deed, the reward must be set accordingly.
If a foreign ship has an objection [to the measures adopted] and it becomes necessary to report the matter to Edo, you
may ask the Omura domain to provide ships to guard the foreign ship, as was done previously.
If there are any Southern Barbarians (Westerners) who propagate the teachings of padres, or otherwise commit
crimes, they may be incarcerated in the prison maintained by the Omura domain, as was done previously.
All incoming ships must be carefully searched for the followers of padres.
No single trading city [see 12 below] shall be permitted to purchase all the merchandise brought by foreign ships.
10. Samurai are not permitted to purchase any goods originating from foreign ships directly from Chinese merchants in
6.
7.
8.
When a vassal (kyu nin) receives a grant of a province or a district, he must consider it as a property entrusted to him
on a temporary basis. A vassal may be moved from one place to another, but farmers remain in the same place. Thus
if an unreasonable illegal act is committed [as described above], the vassal will be called upon to account for his
culpable offense. The intent of this provision must be observed.
3.
9.
Nagasaki.
11.
After a list of merchandise brought by foreign ships is sent to Edo, as before you may order that commercial dealings
4. Anyone whose fief is over 200 cho and who can expect two to three thousand kan of rice harvest each year must
may take place without waiting for a reply from Edo.
12.
After settling the price, all white yarns (raw silk) brought by foreign ships shall be allocated to the five trading cities
and other quarters as stipulated.
After settling the price of white yarns (raw silk), other merchandise [brought by foreign ships] may be traded freely
between the [licensed] dealers. However, in view of the fact that Chinese ships are small and cannot bring large
consignments, you may issue orders of sale at your discretion. Additionally, payment for the goods purchased must
be made within twenty days after the price is set.
receive permission from the authorities before becoming a follower of the padre.
Anyone whose fief is smaller than the one described above may, as his conscience dictates, select for himself from
between eight and nine religions.
5.
13.
8.
If a daimyo who has a fief over a province, a district or a village, forces his retainers to become followers of the
padre, he is committing a crime worse than the followers of Honganji who assembled in their temple [to engage in the
14.
Ikko rio t). This will have an adverse effect on [the welfare of] the nation. Anyone who cannot use good judgment in
The date of departure homeward of foreign ships shall not be later than the twentieth day of the ninth month. Any
ships arriving in Japan later than usual shall depart within fifty days of their arrival. As to the departure of Chinese
this matter wil1 be punished.
ships, you may use your discretion to order their departure after the departure of the Portuguese galeota (galleon).
15. The goods brought by foreign ships which remained unsold may not be deposited or accepted from deposit.
16. The arrival in Nagaski of representatives of the five trading cities shall not be later that the fifth day of the seventh
month. Anyone arriving later than that date shall lose the quota assigned to his city.
EXPULSION OF MISSIONARIES, 1587
1
Japan is the country of gods, but has been receiving false teachings from Christian countries. This cannot be tolerated
any further.
Expert Solution
This question has been solved!
Explore an expertly crafted, step-by-step solution for a thorough understanding of key concepts.
This is a popular solution
Trending nowThis is a popular solution!
Step by stepSolved in 3 steps
