According to Gaynor, Laudicella, and Propper (2011), In the U.K., most hospitals are owned by the government, rather than privately held. In a setting where most hospitals are not owned by the government (such as in the U.S.), what effect do you predict that hospital mergers would have on the price of hospital care? Presumably, hospital mergers would lead to reduced competition and higher prices for any given type of care.

According to Gaynor, Laudicella, and Propper (2011), In the U.K., most hospitals are owned by the government, rather than privately held. In a setting where most hospitals are not owned by the government (such as in the U.S.), what effect do you predict that hospital mergers would have on the price of hospital care? Presumably, hospital mergers would lead to reduced competition and higher prices for any given type of care.

EBK HEALTH ECONOMICS AND POLICY

7th Edition

ISBN:9781337668279

Author:Henderson

Publisher:Henderson

Chapter5: Demand For Health And Medical Care

Section: Chapter Questions

Problem 9QAP

See similar textbooks

Similar questions

Some economists have suggested that the best way to control medical costs is to remove the profit incentive for health care providers, particularly hospitals. This would involve making all hospitals not-for-profit institutions. Use the utility maximization model to explain the likely impact such a policy would have on the cost of producing hospital services. What would happen if instead a policy was instituted that reduced barriers to entry in the hospital sector and therefore made the market more competitive?
According to Gaynor, Laudicella, and Propper (2011), Can you think of reasons why hospital mergers might lead to improvements in the quality of care for a given level of inputs (which is one measure of hospital productivity)? Learning by doing may be facilitated by hospital mergers. Large hospitals can achieve more specialization and consequently their costs of care may be lower.
In some countries, such as Canada and UK, direct-to-consumer (DTC) advertising for pharmaceutical products is illegal or tightly controlled. Which of the following is NOT a reason why DTC is tightly controlled? DTC have the potential to drive up spending on drugs and exacerbate moral hazard. DTC makes patients aware of new remedies. DTC can put a strain on doctor-patient relationship when patients demand some drugs that are not necessary or not the best options. Asymmetric information: consumers are not in a good position to determine if a drug is what they need.
Below is the abstract of a recentNational Bureau of Economic Research working paper entitled “Can governments do it better? Merger mania and hospital outcomes in the English NHS” by Martin Gaynor, Mauro Laudicella, and Carol Propper (2011). The literature on mergers between private hospitals suggests that such mergers often produce little benefit. Despite this, the UK government has pursued an active policy of hospital mergers. These mergers are initiated by a regulator, acting on behalf of the public, and justified on the grounds that merger will improve outcomes. We examine whether this promise is met. We exploit the fact that between 1997 and 2006 in England around half the short term general hospitals were involved in a merger, but that politics means that selection for a merger may be random with respect to future performance. We examine the impact of mergers on a large set of outcomes including financial performance, productivity, waiting times and clinical quality and find…
Do you think that the privatization of the Medical Center would improve or worsen the efficiency of the management of its hospitals?
In some countries, such as Canada and UK, direct-to-consumer (DTC) advertising for pharmaceutical products is illegal or tightly controlled. Which of the following is NOT a reason why DTC is tightly controlled? Question 7 options: Asymmetric information: consumers are not in a good position to determine if a drug is what they need. DTC makes patients aware of new remedies. DTC can put a strain on doctor-patient relationship when patients demand some drugs that are not necessary or not the best options. DTC have the potential to drive up spending on drugs and exacerbate moral hazard.
True or False. There is no such thing as “too much competition” in the private hospital market. Be sure to justify your answer.
Imperfect competition and moral hazard. Some economists have argued that moral hazard and monopolistic health care markets are two socially inefficient problems that partially cancel each other out. Relative to the optimal level of health care Q∗, how much health care is provided in the presence of moral hazard? Assume perfectly competitive health care markets. Relative to the optimal level of health care Q∗, how much health care is provided in the presence of monopolistic health care markets? Assume no moral hazard. Write a one-sentence defense of the argument that moral hazard and imperfectly competitive health care markets could combine to provide a good level of health care provision Q.
Physicians’ offices supply some urgent care services (i.e., services patients seek for prompt attention but not for preservation of life or limb). Name three other providers of urgent care services.
From the point of view of economic security, do you think we should privatize the Medical Center? Do you consider that more or less government intervention is needed in the management of the Medical Center in terms of what services to produce, how to produce the services and for whom to produce them? Do you think that the privatization of the Medical Center would improve or worsen the efficiency of managing its hospitals?
what is the relationship between the financial well-being of the industry and availability of healthcare, in consideration of market and demand theories?
The Stark laws (1989 and 1993) ban physicians from referring patients to facilities in which the physician has a financial interest, such as a specialty hospital, radiation lab, or clinical lab. The Stark laws address: the problem of adverse selection. the high standards imposed on the agency relationship between physician and patient. moral hazard on the part of doctors. induced demand by physicians. unethical behavior by patients.