preview

Youth And Crime By John Muncie

Better Essays

Critically discuss the assertion that “young people are propelled into crime through circumstances beyond their control” (Muncie, 2005, p.116).

In his 2005 book "Youth and Crime", John Muncie stated that “young people are propelled into crime through circumstances beyond their control”. While this may be true in part, there have been many studies written since which differ significantly. Conversely, there are also studies that are at least in part, if not wholly in line with his findings.

Whether the motivation is greed or or the result of environmental factors, it is not known as to whether there is a definitive cause for criminal behaviour. There are myriad causal factors of youth crime, however Muncie had his mind set on the theory that it was something you were born with, not something brought on by conditioning or the result of external environmental tormentors.

Muncie based his theory on a study that took place in the early twentieth century. Several attempts were made by Goring (1913) to determine a certain set of physical characteristics that only criminals had. According to Goring, his study proved that all criminals were born into delinquency and so young people could not help but be forced into a life of crime. To arrive at this conclusion, Goring took over 3,000 male prisoners into various communities around London and then compared them to various control groups of non prisoners. He then used correlation analysis and found that the average criminal tended

Get Access