preview

Yoga And Cancer

Decent Essays

Implementing Yoga in Women with Breast Cancer
A Critical Appraisal and Synthesis
A total of five research articles incorporating yoga practices in women with a diagnosis of breast cancer were analyzed. Four out of the five articles reviewed were noted to be random controlled trials (RCT). These four RCT’s compared women diagnosed with breast cancer, who implemented the practice of yoga exercising, to a control group of women who did not (Rao, et al., 2015; Taso, et al., 2014; Vadiraja, et al., 2009). One RCT compared these women with an additional group, who participated in stretching exercises (Chandwani, et al., 2014). Various outcomes were recorded, such as quality of life, depression, anxiety and fatigue in both groups to determine …show more content…

2014; Rao et al., 2015; Taso et al., 2014; Thomas, et al., 2014; & Vadiraja, et al., 2009).
Disagreements between Articles:
• Two of the studies found that yoga did not influence the level of depression, while the other three showed a decrease in depression with integration of yoga (citation needed)
• One study did not mention if the women were undergoing treatment, rather the disability associated with having breast cancer (Thomas, et al., 2014).
Strengths and Weaknesses of Articles
• Strengths: o Studies who extended following up displayed greater advancements in fatigue levels during the duration of their experiments (citation needed) o Data supports yoga being a positive experience for women with disabilities in connection to breast cancer (citation needed) o Data collection has implications for nursing research and goes beyond the body of work to demonstrate the blurring of traditional boundaries between interventions and data collection (citation needed) o One study showed that there was higher adherence with yoga sessions that took place at the same location as radiotherapy (citation needed)
• Weaknesses: o Study groups were not blinded and treatment expectations were not assessed (citation needed) o Yoga practices focused mainly on the physical aspect as opposed to the mental aspect, which could affect mental health variables (citation needed)

Get Access