As Gandhi once said, “In a gentle way you can shake the world.” He is saying that fighting in a peaceful way and using civil disobedience can change the world. Civil disobedience is the refusal to follow certain laws, as a peaceful form of political protest. Some ways to use civil disobedience boycotting, picketing, and not paying taxes. There has been a long argument over if civil disobedience is an ineffective or ineffective method of social change. I think it is an ineffective way of social change. I think it is ineffective because there can be violence on one side, it can cause consequences, and it takes a long time to make a change.
One reason that civil disobedience is ineffective, is because it creates violence on one side. For example, the Amritsar Massacre shows how civil disobedience creates violence on one side. Gandhi helped organize a nationwide protest against the Rowlatt Acts. The Rowlatt act banned public meeting and gathering and you were not allowed to have public order. Indians then gathered in Amritsar and the British troops came and killed more than 350 unarmed
…show more content…
Susan B. Anthony shows how civil disobedience causes consequences. She was fighting for women’s rights to vote. In 1872 she voted illegally. Susan B. Anthony then got arrested after that act of civil disobedience (Susan B. Anthony, 2).That shows that civil disobedience is ineffective because she got arrested and women didn’t get the right to vote until after she died. So, she spent her time in jail and didn’t even make a change. In addition, Susan B. Anthony also got fined one hundred dollars after she voted illegally (Susan B. Anthony, 2). That shows it causes consequences because she got fined and she didn’t even get to see a change made. If someone keeps doing acts of civil disobedience, they can end up paying a lot more than she did. That is how civil disobedience causes
Civil Disobedience has been around for hundreds of years. This a practice first put into play by a man by the name of Henry David Thoreau who believed that if you didn’t agree with a rule then you should act against it in a nonviolent way, and be willing to accept any punishment that comes with it. His teachings were followed by famous activists such as Ghandi, and Martin Luther King Jr., and many others.
“There will never be complete equality until women themselves help to make laws and elect lawmakers,” Anthony said this in 1897 (Documented). This quote shows how strongly Anthony feels about women’s suffrage, because she knows that it is her basic human right to be able to vote. Susan B. Anthony’s involvement in civil disobedience was due to personal influence, she chose to participate in civil disobedience to protest for women’s suffrage, and she did make a difference in the cause of women’s suffrage but never seen the day that women got the right to vote. Civil Disobedience is when you break a law to protest for something you believe in (Suber). People use civil disobedience because they believe it is a nonviolent way yo get a point across
Civil disobedience activist, Susan B. Anthony once said, “Failure is impossible.” Anthony stuck with this belief through her fight for women's rights, and in the end, proved it to be true. Susan B. Anthony’s involvement in civil disobedience was due to personal influences, she chose to participate in civil disobedience to protest slavery, but is most popularly known for her role in the fight for women’s rights, and she ultimately achieved success using this controversial method of standing up for what she strongly believes to be right. Civil disobedience is an act of protesting and breaking a law in hopes to change it; people who do this are usually peaceful and accept punishment for their crime (Suber). The purpose
The Civil Rights Movement is a substantial example of civil disobedience for the reason that they were peacefully protesting while accepting their consequences. On the other hand, people today believe that they're protesting peacefully however, peace can lead to violence and take away the credibility of their cause. Causing destruction in their community, where civil disobedience impacts society negatively because the situations get out of hand that cause chaotic cases which involves brutality.
Another example of civil disobedience is when Susan B. Anthony voted in 1872 when women were not allowed to vote (One Woman, One Vote). Based on the evidence, one can conclude that women raised awareness by being civilly disobedient because they led non-violent protests that made the United States look bad. When Anthony was arrested for voting in 1872, she demanded to be handcuffed. When Alice Paul went on a hunger strike, she was forced to eat. Both of these historical events made the United States look unprofessional.
Susan B. Anthony and Civil Disobedience Civil rights activist, Susan B. Anthony once said, “We ask justice, we ask equality, we ask that all the civil and political rights that belong to citizens of the United States, be guaranteed to us and our daughter forever” (Susan B. Anthony Pintrest). Susan B. Anthony was an outstanding citizen and a feminist who fought strongly of what she believed in. Civil disobedience is when people are drawing attention to a law they don’t believe in and know they may have to go to jail for breaking the law. The purpose of civil disobedience is to change laws and rules that may be seen as unfair. Susan B Anthony’s involvement in Civil Disobedience was due to personal influences, (Susan B. Anthony Bio) she chose to participate in civil disobedience to protest for women’s rights, and she did achieve success using this controversial method of standing up for what she strongly believed to be right.
“First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win.” This quote spoken by historical figure Mohandas K. Gandhi tells how civil disobedience works in fifteen words. Gandhi was a man who used civil disobedience to get what he wanted. This quote reflects on how being peaceful while breaking a government’s laws can lead to results. Civil Disobedience is the refusal to obey certain laws and legally protest against the government’s laws by picketing, boycotting and the refusal to pay taxes. Many people have different opinions about civil disobedience. Some people believe that civil disobedience is not effective as a means of social change. For example, some may say that using civil disobedience will take a long
Civil Disobedience: The Tools of Progress Since the beginning of days, peaceful protests have pushed the world along. Many people view civil disobedience as a violent action that hardly ever succeeds. However, true civil disobedience, the peaceful protestation of laws, is extremely helpful to society. When those who are oppressed show discontent without violence it is easier for the oppressor to see the other side. Truly peaceful protests achieve change while violent ones only serve as an excuse to dismiss a cause as dangerous or unprofessional.
When people decide to engage in acts of civil disobedience to cause a positive change in their society, they make certain sacrifices that have consequences on their appearance in society. Despite the progress people have made by committing civil disobedience, what they do is typically illegal and can lead to them being arrested. For example, Susan B. Anthony committed an act of civil disobedience by voting in an election before women had the right to vote. As a result, she was arrested, went to trial, and was given a fine of $100.
Civil disobedience plays an important and great role in the world. It is a major and effective part of many processes that combat injustice and immorality. In the past, it has helped countries gain independence, combatted racial segregation, affected countries’ involvement in wars and much more. People such as Parks and Gandhi have fought the immoral laws which led to thousands of millions of people having the opportunity to live a future without prejudice, discrimination and oppression because they held up their beliefs and demonstrated he importance of civil
One of the most famous acts of peaceful disobedience was by Rosa Parks. Rosa Parks went against the Jim Crow laws and would not give up her seat for a white man, who was at the time her superior because she was a black woman. She was arrested because she refused. When she was arrested, it sparked the protest of all public busses that lasted over a year, which was led by Martin Luther King, Jr. This also created a court case against “Alabama’s discriminatory laws” that was taken to the
Susan B. Anthony was a participant in civil disobedience due to the unequal rights or women she states later, “I do not demand equal pay for any women save those who do equal work in value. Scom to be coddled by your employers; make them understand that you are in their service as workers, not as women.” (Susan B. Anthony). Susan B. Anthony’s involvement in civil disobedience was due to personal influences, he/she chose to participate in civil disobedience to protest voting laws, ands he did achieve success using this controversial method of standing up for what she strongly believes to be right. Civil disobedience is a form of protesting in a peaceful manner which protesters willingly break the law accepting the consequences of their actions.
Throughout history Civil Disobedience has had nothing but positive impacts for our nation. The people are trying to improve the government the only way they know how. In 1847 Henry David Thoreau, a philosopher, wrote in his essay on civil disobedience “I ask, for not at once no government, but at once a better government.” A great example for a leap for rights would be the Montgomery Bus Boycott. On December 5th of 1955, African Americans took a vow not to take the bus as a silent and peaceful protest for segregation seating, this lasted 381 days. Finally, the U.S Supreme Court integrated their bus system. The boycott was only the start of the American Civil Rights Movement. Segregation was a big problem that we don't see much these days because people
Civil Disobedience is remarkably effective without the violence that many had thought necessary. Several famous examples include the Salt March of Mahatma Gandhi, the Civil Rights movement of Martin Luther King Jr., and even the sit-ins of the factory workers during the industrial revolution. Although, many still argue that civil
Sometimes, there is no way for their voices to be heard unless they use actions instead of words. Civilly disobeying a law allows citizens to voice their opinions without harming other people. Rosa Parks believed she should not have to give up her seat on the bus and disobeyed a law without using her words and therefore drew attention to the oppression African-Americans faced during that time. Rosa Parks civilly disobeyed an unjust segregation law that not many people at the time would be willing to verbally and physically disobey. Because of Rosa Parks and her act of civil disobedience, the American Civil rights movement was recognized as a serious