Who is truly responsible for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet? As a reader finishes Romeo and Juliet, a play about tragic teenage love, by William Shakespeare they are often left wondering who is to blame. There are many causes, but some of them had more of an impact than others. The reasons for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet are the feud, irrational decisions, and the friar and the nurse. The feud was one of the main reasons for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. If the feud had not been there they would not have been afraid to show their love. As written in the prologue “From ancient grudge break to new mutiny. Where civil blood makes civil hands unclean. From forth the fatal loins of these two foes. A pair of star-crossed lovers take their life.”(prologue.3-6) This shows how because of the feud Romeo and Juliet took their lives. The feud was also the reason for so much conflict and death in the first place. This caused Romeo to be punished. The prince said that because Romeo killed Tybalt he should be banished (3.2.196-197) The feud was not the only reason for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet. …show more content…
When Friar Laurence and Juliet came up with the solution to fake her death instead of telling her parents. He gives her a sleeping potion and tells her to not let anyone sleep in the room(4.1.91-122) This is an extremely irrational decision and something was bound to go wrong. Romeo also made many irrational decisions. These included killing Tybalt and Rushing to Verona right after he heard Juliet had died. If he hadn’t done these things the tragedy would not have happened. There were also other reasons for the tragedy of Romeo and
Did you ever wonder what was the main reason for the deaths in Romeo & Juliet. This play is about Romeo & Juliet by William Shakespeare. The story started off with two families fuding. Romeo, one of the main characters, in love with another woman. He was later rejected by her, and then turned into a state of depression. His friend, Mercutio, decided that he should go to a party to get over the rejection. When Romeo arrived he looked for Rosaline, instead he found Juliet. Him and Juliet fell in love the same night, later they decided to get married. The next day they married, and Romeo went home to get ready to celebrate. On his way home Mercutio and Tybalt got into a fight causing Mercutio to die. Romeo killed Tybalt, then got banished. Juliet
Romeo and Juliet were two young people from feuding families, who fell in love. Their love was so strong, that they ended up dying for each other. The ironic twist at the end of the story surprised many who had read it. But who is to blame for this tragedy? Many characters in this play could be to blame. We believe that some of the characters to blame are Capulet, Friar Lawrence, plus Romeo and Juliet themselves.
Who was to blame for the tragic deaths of Romeo and Juliet? Two star-crossed lovers with a forbidden love and so many obstacles to overcome, but in the end it wasn't enough. Was it the fault of the two families and their bitter feud, or perhaps the Friar and the Nurse, or was it all just destiny in the two young lover's fate...
The next reason Friar Laurence is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet is because he trusted Juliet a 14 year old girl with the situation. Friar Laurence stated “If thou hast the strength of will to slay thyself, take thou this vial…no warmth, no breath shall testify the livest” (4.1.72, 93, and 98). Friar Laurence says if she takes the potion no one will be able to tell if she is dead or not. If Friar Laurence did not give Juliet the potion, Juliet would have never been in a position she was uncomfortable in doing. Which led her to her
Who is Responsible for the Tragic Deaths of Romeo and Juliet 'Romeo and Juliet', a tragedy written by William Shakespeare in the 16th Century all about two strong hearted teenagers in the city of Verona in Italy who fall in love with each other as 'star crossed lovers'. The two young teenagers of feuding families were destined to fall in love, however many problems occur to the extent of suicide, that affect their relationship, one of the main factors is the feud between their two families. Juliet is a Capulet and Romeo is a Montague.
Even though there are many different views on who was most responsible for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, through information in the text it is clear to see that Friar Laurence was most responsible. The Friar took it upon himself to marry the two in secret making them inseparable. The Friar came up with the plan that was doomed from the start and ultimately lead to the death of the two teens. William Shakespeare’s work was very controversial, Romeo and Juliet was no exception, it involved the death of many people and two suicides of teens just for
In Shakespeare’s classic play, Romeo and Juliet, the prologue refers to the title characters as “star-cross’d lovers” with a “death-mark’d love”, showing that the two are doomed from the start (Shakespeare 3). Being from two opposing families that are in a never-ending feud, Romeo and Juliet 's love is forbidden. However, throughout the novel, the lovers defy their parents and pursue their fast-forming love with the help of supporting characters, such as Friar Lawrence, who are seemingly presented as beneficial characters that help the story progress. However, it can be argued that these ”beneficial characters” are actually interfering with their relationship, and are a key factor in contributing to their deaths. Although fate is seemingly
The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet is a book of fate and how everyone in the world affects the happenings of this world. The author of this extraordinary book is William Shakespeare. Although Romeo and Juliet killed themselves, there were many people responsible for their deaths. It is arguable that the parents of the two lovers, Friar Laurence, and Romeo and Juliet themselves were the most responsible, some could say that the other main characters like Mercutio, Benvolio, Tybalt, the Nurse, and Paris were involved as well. There were many people responsible for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, although they took their own lives, they were not all to blame.
Friar Laurence makes not only one, but three mistakes that will eventually lead up to Romeo and Juliet’s death. The Friar’s first mistake was giving Juliet, an unstable fourteen year old, a powerful potion that would make her look dead, so she would not have to marry Paris. Friar Laurence actually shows his irresponsibility by saying, “Thou hast the strength of will to slay thyself…take thou this vial…no warmth, no breath shall testify the livest”( Act 4.1.). Had Friar Laurence not given Juliet the poison, she never would have been put in the position that she was in, which lead to her death.
Romantic love stories are often ended with a tragedy, because of loss of passion or a loved one. These tragedies are often the result of one person’s actions that ended someone’s life or love. In the Romeo and Juliet play written by William Shakespeare, two citizens of Verona come together and fall deeply in love. Unfortunately their love comes to an end, along with their lives, because of a misunderstanding and a persistent feud between their families. Although there are many characters in this play that have contributed to Romeo and Juliet’s death, Friar Laurence is the person most to blame.
In the tragic romance, Romeo and Juliet, William Shakespeare displays an example of how teenage love can embrace the feelings of the young but also cause destruction, not only in their lives but also the people’s lives around them. This story shows how others opinions and thoughts can affect the people close to them. But who is responsible for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet? The death of these star crossed lovers was not only the teenagers fault but also their family and friends such as, their parents, Friar Lawrence, and the nurse.
Another mistake that Friar Laurence made was conjuring up a plan that involves Juliet taking a sleeping potion. “Take thou this vial, being then in bed, And this distilling liquor drink thou off...” “…stiff and stark and cold appear, like death, And this borrowed likeness of shrunk death, Thou shalt continue two and forty hours, And then wake as from a pleasant sleep. (Act 4- Scene 1, Pg. 99)” The plan that Friar Laurence was speaking of was Juliet taking a potion that made her seem as though she was dead for forty- two hours. The family, believing her to bed dead, would have her taken to the Capulet burial vault. When she would awaken, Romeo would have already been informed of the plan and be there to take there to Mantua. His convincing Juliet to take the potion is another reason to blame for the death is because he never considered what would happen if the potion did not allow Juliet to return from her “pleasant sleep”. Romeo would have thought that Friar Laurence had killed her by giving her poison and then he would be executed for killing Friar Laurence in his rage of anger.
Romeo and Juliet's death could have been prevented, if they were not together. Friar Laurence marries Romeo and Juliet, this was the first mistake which would lead to their deaths. A bond between them was created through marriage: "For, by your leaves, you shall not stay alone / Till holy church incorporate two in one." (113, 39-40). None of any of the tragedies would have occurred if Romeo and Juliet were not married. Friar laurence keeps the secret of the new marriage only to himself he doesn't tell another couplet or montage. The reason why this is a big deal, and why friar laurence is the one to blame, because if he told the capulets that Juliet married another boy, the capulets may not have pressured and forced Juliet to marry another boy. Friar laurence also came up with a secret plan that nobody knew besides him and Julliet. The plan was to drink a potion to act dead for 42 hours, and when she awakes Romeo will be there and they will run off,”I wake before the time that Romeo come to redeem me? ….with a club dash out my Brian's” (190,
Another thing that can be used as evidence to show this is a feud is the sheer length of the affair, in which there is several fights with no sign of either side backing down, until the Prince shows up and declares that if there are anymore 'disagreements' there will be dire consequences, the fact of the Prince getting involved also shows that the feud is a big thing, that, and the punishment of death if there is another fight, shows this is a full throttle family war underpinning the whole play affecting and infecting everything, mainly Romeo and Juliet's love for each other, everything would've been fine if not for the families feuding.
One reason why the feud is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet is that the rivalry turns their love from something lighthearted into something dark. This becomes apparent in Act 2 Scene 2 when Romeo climbs over the Capulet wall to see Juliet after a party. Once Romeo arrives