According to the article written by Simon Worrall, “Yes, Animals Think And Feel. Here’s How We Know,” he writes,“It seems illogical for us to think that animals might not be having a conscious mental experience of play, sleep, fear or love”(“Think and Feel”). What the quote means is that dismissing the idea that animals know how to show emotion is seems cold-hearted and narrowed minded to think they do not. The topic that I will argue is that animals know how to express emotion. This will be a question of fact (because of popular belief that animals do not express emotion). My goal is to inform. I would like for people to know that us humans are not the only ones that are conscious and aware on this earth, but also that animals are as well. …show more content…
According to the article,”Which Emotions do Dogs Actually Experience?” written by Stanley Coren who is a psychology professor and a neuropsychological researcher writes about what people feel are also what dogs feel and the development of emotions in both an infant and a dog and when their emotions start to grow in the upcoming years. In Coren’s article, he writes,”Dogs also have the same hormones and undergo the same chemical changes that humans do during emotional states. Dogs even have the hormone oxytocin, which, in humans, is involved with feeling love and affection for others. With the same neurology and chemistry that people have, it seems reasonable to suggest that dogs also have emotions that are similar to ours. However it is important to not go overboard and immediately assume that the emotional ranges of dogs and humans are the same”(“Dogs Actually Experience”). What he means is that the hormones that trigger love or happiness in people also happens in dogs, but not to be under the assumption that dogs possess every emotion that humans feel. What he also writes in his article is,”Dogs go through their developmental stages much more quickly than humans do, and have all of the emotional range that they will ever achieve by the time they are four to six …show more content…
While on the other hand, others argue that animals do not have emotions, but their emotions is what that animal perceives and what they are aware of. According to the article,”Five Myths and Five Truths About Emotions: Part Two,” written by doctor Steve Orma, a clinical psychologist, recognized mental health expert, and specialist in the treatment of insomnia, anxiety, and stress, writes how emotions are perceived and dispels some of the assumptions that people have had. According to Steve Orma,”Animals don’t experience emotions like human beings do. This is because we have a rational mind that can think abstractly and conceptually. Animals are only perceptual beings, and therefore their emotions are based on physical sensations, such as pleasure and pain, comfort and discomfort. For example, a dog might cry when you leave him home alone. But, this is not the same as a woman crying when her husband goes off to war. The dog is only aware (perceptually) that you are not there and he’s ‘sad’ because he’s not getting attention, affection, or food”(“Five Myths and Five Truths”). What he basically says is that the emotions that animals feel is only what they physically feel and that they only get sad when they do not get attention or when they are hungry, so what is perceived as animals having emotions is nothing but a false assumption. Although that may be true, but according to the
emotions in a ‘man-made’ species is not far off in a non-organic life-form, but the question with
In chapter seven, it talks about emotions which are internal sensations that are shaped by physiology, perceptions, language, and social experiences. It is said that we feel emotions when external stimuli cause a physiological change in our bodies. For example, before and while giving my identity presentation, I felt anxious and nervous. I knew this because I was sweating, light-headed, and my stomach was turning. Another example for me would be whenever I get extremely mad because it feels like my whole body is on fire.
Emotions are used in everyday life, whether it be just a simple smile that makes happiness disperse in your brain, or a death of a loved one that causes sadness. The basic emotions are joy, interest, surprise, sadness, anger, disgust, contempt, fear, shame, and guilt. The way we see emotion in ourselves and others can be very complex because we sometimes assume they feel a certain way just based on their actions or even facial expressions. When emotion is discussed in psychological terms, it is not based on one thing, instead it’s a mix of bodily arousal, expressive behaviors, conscious experience. Many theories try to explain how emotion works.
In the article, “Do Dogs Ever Simply want to Die to End the Pain?” by Marx Bekoff published in the Huffington Post. He believes that dogs suffer dramatic trauma where Winograd does not. In the article, “Irremediable Psychological Suffering? There’s No Such Thing” by Nathan J. Winograd also published in the Huffington Post believes that animals do not feel emotions like humans. Marc Bekoff was more persuasive in his article because not only did he give us positive information, but he gave us examples of how animals really do feel emotions.
Thus, besides through our perspective, an interpretation based on an animal perspective is demanded, but due to an insurmountable fact that we’re not animals so we cannot possibly know their feelings and thoughts, it starts to get tricky when we’re trying to delve into the animal world. For animals’ immeasurable cognitive, we might apply Behaviorism, the study of stimulus and responses, and neural-data to measure; nevertheless, whether these techniques are effective is being questioned, because no animal ever stands out to express its feeling and prove the theory. Generally we hypothesize that “animals may feel emotions and that human emotions evolved from the same mechanisms,”(Panksepp, J. (1982). "Toward a general psychobiological theory of emotions”.) but is it fair to assume that animals have same feelings and way of thinking as we do, while admitting countless differences between us and them? From my understanding, I don't think this assumption is valid. Take pain as an example: we human regard pain as an obstacle on way to “happy life”, so we justify everything we do could console suffering animals but ignore to contemplate whether animals need our help. During the evolution, animals including early human beings developed pain, a signal warning for damage and a cue to survival. Later then human beings’ rapid development stayed ahead of those of all other species, starting to discriminate us from other animals. With time passing, such discrepancy grew larger and larger. By cooperations, human being acts as a unity and created societies, where mature food chains and comprehensive medical system gradually developed. The more concretely our society develops, the less we depend on pain as a tool for survival.
Rifkin is evidently right about how animals express their emotions and have similarities to us humans. This article
One of the few good points that Rifkin has is that yes animals do have emotion, yes they are intelligent. But, so is every other living thing on this planet. We are called intelligent life forms for a reason. It’s a part of life on earth to kill for own personal gain, it’s been this way since the dinosaurs millions of years ago. And even if we didn’t harm the animals in ANY way shape or form, they would still fall victim
The human’s body language emits a sad aura which the dog is able to comprehend. Whether the owner gets in a fight, feeling sick, or they just do not feel jovial, the dogs help motivates the humans up to not be sad. Knowing this fact, shows that dogs has not malicious intent. In an interview with Ms. Le, a dog walker from my neighborhood, she claims that, “Sometimes when I feel sad, my Dachshund would try to comfort me and bring me his favorite toy” (Le). If it hurts the humans, the dogs knows that is going wrong, they will feel glum with their humans.
Do animals feel joy, love, fear, anguish or despair? What ere emotions, and perhaps more importantly, how do scientists prove animals are capable of emotion? Sea lion mothers have often been seen wailing painfully and squealing eerily as they watch their babies being eaten by killer whales. Buffaloes have also been observed sliding playfully across ice, excitedly screaming “Gwaaa.” Emotions are defined broadly as psychological phenomena that help in behavioral management and control. This is a challenging question to researchers who are trying to determine the answer to this question. Through current research by close observation combined with neurobiological research, evidence that animals exhibit fear, joy
In fictional cartoons, animals are usually portrayed with emotions just like humans. In mostly comedic and colorful animation, they would be seen crying over spilled milk or smirking after dropping the punch line. But in reality, it is actually scientifically proven that our pet dogs do have emotions. So, remember that time your dog smiled at you and you were not quite sure if it means anything? Well, maybe it was the relaxing tummy rub you were doing back then.
I learned in chapter seven of children of emotions. A researcher named michael lewis who has has state that there is a differences in emotion. There are emotions that are found in every person and animals called primary emotions. Primary emotions are anger, fear, sadness, joy, interest, and disgust, they present themselves in the first six month. Then according to lewis self- conscious emotion that requires that a child is conscious of their own sense of being. Those emotions are pride, shame, empathy, jealousy, and embarrassment which usually don’t appear until around a six months to two years. Though it has been debated that self awareness don’ts happen until around eighteen months. I think it's interesting to learn about the emotion that infants might feel.
The Death of a Salesman follows one character in particular, Willy Loman. Willy has a wife named Linda and two sons, Biff and Happy. I think that Willy has something physiologically wrong with him. At points in the play, he gets extremely angry at his wife and sons for no reason at all. Even though Linda is super sweet to him and always takes care of him, he is rude to her. In addition to his physiological problems, Willy believes that committing suicide will benefit his family more than his physical presence. Also, he believes that more money will be available for the family after his death. Throughout the play, Willy’s profession is a salesman. Since his job does not pay well, he has to borrow money from his neighbor. Each time his
Charles Darwin was the first scientist to ever study animals in a systematic way (Bekoff “The Emotional Lives” 6). In his book The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, Darwin discussed the
Having established evidence of the ability of dogs to experience negative emotions, the goal of finding proof of positive emotions remained. It was hoped that Link would provide the evidence needed,
In the video “The Power of Words” a homeless man is on the side of the streets wanting money and wasn't getting much until a woman came along and wrote on his sign and it made a major difference in what people were given. The first sign said “I'm blind and homeless” but once the lady came by the sign said “It’s a beautiful day and I can’t see it”. The quotes show how words have power. If someone wrote something in vague way it might not provide a strong mental image or stronger feelings. If the same thing was dec=scribed in a better way with better words and more general description they will have stronger feeling or a better mental mage towards what is being described.