preview

Where The Sidewalk Ends By Shel Silverstein

Decent Essays

“Listen to the mustn’ts, the shouldn’ts, the impossibles, the won’ts, and the never haves. Then, listen to me. Anything can happen, child. Anything can be.” This is a poem the famous children’s poet Shel Silverstein. Now, if he was best known for being a children’s author, how could he even be considered to be controversial? Now, Shel Silverstein, while having no earlier inspiration for his career to draw and write for children, wrote many famous poem books, such as Falling Up and Where the Sidewalk Ends: however, with him writing these books came some controversy with it, such as claims that he promoted cannibalism and suicide. As a child, Shel Silverstein was enclosed to his school and never had any famous inspiration to start writing, and …show more content…

The three biggest books based on popularity were The Giving Tree, Where the Sidewalk Ends, and Falling Up. Starting with The Giving Tree, the book starts with a small boy and an apple tree. Throughout the boy’s life, the apple tree gives to the boy its apples, its shade, its wood for building, and finally, when the boy had grown to be an old, elder man, the stump of the tree to rest on. Through all of this, the boy and the tree were happy. His first of three poem books, Where the Sidewalk Ends, was wildly successful because of its telling of humorous and witty nature but uses that silliness to cover the ideas of what’s really happening in the story with childhood fantasies. For example, one of his poems titled “Hug O’ War” explains that he would “not play at tug o' war. I’d rather play at hug o' war where here everyone hugs instead of tugs”. In his other well-received poem book, Falling Up, it has the same idea as his other two, but his ideas in this one seemed to try and appeal to both children and adults alike by adding illustrations and wording to please both …show more content…

However, there are some hidden themes, some think, that promote some extreme subjects that no child should ever read. For example, some claim that, just because of his earlier career with Playboy, his illustrations in his poem books are ‘suggestive’ to sexual desires and the like. Some psychologists claim the book The Giving Tree suggests a “vicious, one-sided abusive relationship” between the tree and the boy where the tree was the selfless giver and the boy the greedy person who takes but never gives. Finally, an elementary school in Mukwonago, Wisconsin claimed that the themes that were in Where the Sidewalk Ends promoted “drug use, suicide, death, Satan, and cannibalism”.On the contrary, many people praised Silverstein for his nature of writing, going beyond people that, at the time, had not dared to write about. He wrote that people can have their own opinions and that, if we could stop having hate in the world, maybe, just maybe, we could have a “great big hug over the world, full of

Get Access