preview

Victoria Police Force

Better Essays

PREAMBLE
The use of force by police is a fundamental power delegated to them to enable pursuit of their doctrine to protect and serve the greater community. Indeed, so intrinsic is this power to police, that Victoria Police invariably refer to themselves as “The Force”. It is essentially only this power which differentiates the police from the rest of us, a state sanctioned ability to manage harm in order to arrest and subdue law breaking citizens. As a society we accept police powers of arrest and force as a necessity in the maintenance of law and order and so public discourse in this matter is generally limited to cases of excess use of force, especially those resulting in fatalities. This paper aims to explore current issues in the practical …show more content…

Police media spokespersons usually speak out in support of their officer’s decisions immediately following the fatal use of force with the entirety of their media department available to manipulate public opinion in their favour. This was the case with Tyler Cassidy – immediate and unequivocally favourable support was provided to the officers simply based on initial reports. Surely a matter such as unusual as the police shooting of a 15 year old requires a more careful analysis than the defensive knee-jerk response given by Victoria Police. This blind loyalty is a major reason for the necessity of impartiality and independence when investigating such matters. Judgements should be reserved for the State Coroner to decide as there naturally exists a conflict of interest when investigating one’s own friends and …show more content…

The recent history of instances of shooting deaths by police in Victoria has experienced major swings in proper implementation of policy from before Project Beacon to the current climate. A troubled Tyler Cassidy found himself in a policing environment too resistant and incapable of responding to rising concerns regarding necessary changes in police practice. The police culture of protecting their own not only hindered efforts to reform police training concerning appropriate risk assessment when considering the use of force, but also served to undermine the authenticity and accuracy of investigative processes which are key in proving accountability for misjudgement. Pragmatic and results based reform in the practices of deadly force is clearly required to avoid recurrence of tragedies resembling Tyler’s however this will be very difficult to achieve in a system that has written off the homicide as justifiable. A collaborative effort to inform policy between police and criminologists as well as a more independent review processes in similar cases may just help bridge the divide between ideal procedures and the current

Get Access