preview

Ust Case Solution

Decent Essays

Key Issue 2: Is $1b appropriate to enhance UST’s firm value and ultimately shareholder value?

Higher leverage is very likely to create value for a firm considering capital structure change by exerting financial discipline and more efficient corporate strategy changes.
Before evaluating whether $1b is value enhancing in quantitative measure, ability to cope with pre-requisite interest payment and potentially dividend payment (possibly dividend growth maintenance) should be considered.

Required debt rate and pro forma income statement

Risk determinants

Credit rating agencies take a wide range of factors – debt raising purpose, industry outlook, corporate profile and financial measures into account when performing corporate …show more content…

UST dividend payment ability can be hampered given the following risk factors: anti-trust dispute is resolved in favor of competitors and UST is subject to further penalty, corporate restructuring or new entrants are encouraged to enter the moist smokeless market; management’s continued lackluster non-core investment performance further harms the company’s return over investment; Price value further prey market share of premium products while premium R&D is not catching up with the pace.

Valuation enhancement and alternative options

Valuation enhancement

Management considering share repurchase program should weigh its benefit of financial discipline, efficient corporate strategy implementation and utilization of tax shield against the downside of cost of financial distress. It’s not the possibility of bankruptcy that causes concerns among equity holders regarding extent of leverage but the direct costs (legal, liquidation, administrative etc.) and indirect costs (deteriorated corporate image, management time and attention, agency costs of value-destructing investment, distress asset sales etc.). Exhibit 4 lists the key assumption inputs of approximating quantitative firm value/ equity value accretion. Levering UST to a larger extent by adding $1,000m does increase firm value.

Valuation addition distribution

However, additional analysis should be done to differentiate value distribution of $328.9m in the case of levering up $1,000m between cash-out

Get Access