The questions are simple? Are Uber drivers considered employees and should they receive the same benefits and perks as the Uber deemed employees? What is the difference between being a contractor and an employee? And why are some many people protesting and debating the issue? Here’s a scenario; Omar, an Uber driver was working one night for Uber as a driver. When he reached the destination for his passengers, they refused to leave his car. From there a fight broke out and Omar was hit in the face with an unidentified shiny object. Omar’s jaw was broken in two places and had a week’s stay in the hospital (Huet, 2015). Many would expect Uber to cover Omar’s hospital expenses and give him some sort of compensation but, no such thing happened. In most cases, a company’s Human Resource department would ensure that the employee received care and all other issues and …show more content…
To reduce the possibility of a lawsuit from the worker, the company will agree to cover the expenses and damages (Huet, 2015). On the other hand, being considered an employee of a company holds that company liabile for any incident that may occur. There are many taxicab, limo and package delivery cases that raise this issue. In franchise operations, the relationship can be even narrower. The facts and circumstances matter and not all cases come out the same way. In Viado v. Domino’s Pizza, LLC, in which Domino’s Pizza faced a $32M Verdict over a fatal pizza delivery accident that left a 65 year-old woman dead and her 70 year-old husband with un- reversible brain injuries. The driver was legally responsible, as well as the independent franchise store. And Domino’s was liable too, in part because the driver was speeding to meet Domino’s 30-minute delivery guarantee. The court said a franchisor like Domino’s can be responsible for the actions of a franchisee’s employee in some
Worker’s Compensation programs first appeared a century ago in the U.S., introduced on a voluntary basis. At a time when few employers provided insurance or benefits for workers injured on the job it provided workers with insurance regardless of negligence at the cost of forfeiting one’s right to sue.
The workplace should be a safe area where you can practice your trade. Employers should provide the appropriate training and safety measures to minimize risk of accident and injury. Sometimes, however, though negligence or accident, injuries occur. Workers’ compensation generally provides for the coverage of medical treatments and lost wages after such incidents. Occasionally, overzealous insurance companies deny claims and leave injured employees wondering where to turn for help.
This is become smart companies prepare return-to-work packets that include job descriptions and available light-duty jobs. Doctors will simply release the injured employee to work, who maintains his dignity, and the company will avoid insurance and OHSA problems. However, some injuries, such as straining a muscle while moving heavy objects or even being harmed in a car accident while making off-site deliveries, may be challenged by unscrupulous workers. For example, if a construction worker who performs the same task for years acquires a repetitive motion injury or musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs), they should consult with a workers’ compensation lawyer. These legal professionals who defend the rights of their clients by working with the occupational doctor to establish medical facts and by challenging the dishonest company’s erroneous
Generally, an employer may be held “vicariously liable” for the negligence of an employee under certain circumstances such as; “the injury occurred while the employee was on the clock, the injury was caused by an activity the employee was hired to perform, and the employer benefited in some way from the activity the employee was performing at the time of the injury”” (findlaw.com
The well-being of an individual is what matters the most to bring out the best in them. Thus as an organization or a company, the well-being of the employees should be considered as the 1st priority. Any injury or medical illness caused to the employee by the work done within the organization shall be compensated by WCB. Most employees do not know that there are ways to fight the WCB and appeal decisions. With proper facts, an employee is ultimately able to get the compensation that is deserved.
Pam’s Pizza shop is not liable for the man’s injuries. Normally, in similar cases, the doctrine of Respondeat Superior may apply. However, Joey’s fails to meet the four tests that courts have used to determine whether an employee’s conduct is within the scope of his or her employment. Granted, it did occur substantially within the time and location authorized, however, the fact that he went to his niece’s birthday was not all in part motivated by the purpose of serving his employer and it was not in any way the kind of work he was employed to do. Therefore, I believe Joey was more on a “frolic” of his own and his act was not within the scope of employment because it occurred within an independent course of conduct not intended by the employee
In the article Uber drivers are employees, not contractors, Canadian lawsuit argues, Kristine Owram sheds light on this proposed Ontario class action lawsuit. This lawsuit was launched by Samfiru Tumarkin LLP against Uber technologies Inc. They are seeking $200 million in damages on behalf of all drivers working for Uber since 2012. The plaintiff argues that the drivers have been misclassified as contractors, and are therefore entitled to minimum wage, overtime pay, and vacation pay. They believe that “duties performed by the class members and the supervision and control imposed on the class members by Uber creates an employment relationship with Uber” (Owram, 2017). The defence (Uber) argues that the flexibility that corresponds with the
Jacks current policy does not provide coverage if he were to use his personal vehicle for driving Uber customers (College for America, 2014). The exclusion section page 4, of the personal automobile insurance policy clearly explains that the policy will not cover the loss of any bodily injury, damages, or medical payment if the vehicle is operated in use as a public or livery conveyance. The policy clearly excludes coverage for any loss to your covered auto or any non-owned auto, which occurs while it is being used as public or livery conveyance (College for America, 2014). The benefits of the policy that is provided by Uber to its drivers are that the insurance for the automobile would start when the rider enters the vehicle and would stop
In today’s workforce, employees are protected in the event of a workplace accident or illness. The Worker’s Compensation program allows for the
In those situations, employers will have to provide financial compensation as a result of the injury. When the injury that occurs is a normal progression of the employee’s pre-existing condition, the employer will not be responsible for paying financial compensation as a result of that injury.
The Italian restaurant could fight for negligence in court, about the customers for being terrified, and freaking out in a bad manner going through this couldn’t most likely be held in court. The restaurant is trying to act like the suspect, and they are trying show how the negligence in their statement of being terrified, and freaking out, eventually results of the injuries. The staff members in the Italian restaurant that’s injured could’ve made the claim against the restaurant using workmen’s compensation showing that there’s being injury at the job. This is shown to be the staff member acting as the plaintiff vs. the defendant and the restaurant.
1. Medical Expense. If an employee gets sick or injured on the job, worker's comp will pay for medical expense like Emergency Room, blood test, X-rays, and other generally acceptable medical services. Each states has their own rules in order to get those medical expenses covered. ( For instance in Florida drug test requires for sick or injured employees before or after receiving medical care. Denial on taking drug test can lead to termination or suspension depending on employer.). Majority of those medical claims are covered.
The employee also had to prove his or her incident, which consist of seeing if there was any witnesses to prove that the accident was out of their control but, also that they were really hurt for the accident, drug test to prove that they was not on any type of medication at the time of the injury. Before the 1900’s all of that was true employees’ was being forced to accept responsibility because there was no laws set in place to protect them. It wasn’t until 1911 that the liability laws was set into place and adopted by different states, this law is called Workers’ Compensation. “Worker’s Compensation Insurance helps an employee who has been injured on the
Typically, no insurances were offered to them for injuries at workplaces. This placed them in a difficult situation, especially if one’s injured, the value of labor power declines and they will either become non-hireable or will only be offered unpaid work.
Workers’ compensation provides cash and medical benefits to workers who are injured or become ill in the course of their employment and benefits to the survivors of workers killed on the job. Benefits are provided without regard to fault and are the exclusive remedy for workplace injuries, illnesses, and deaths. Nearly all workers and employers in the United States are covered by workers’ compensation and each state, with the exception of Texas, has a mandatory workers’ compensation system. In 2105 more than 135 million workers accounting for more than $7.1 trillion in wages, were covered by a state or federal workers’ compensation system. When a covered worker is injured becomes sick or dies as a result of his or her employment, that worker is entitled to full medical coverage for the injury or illness, cash benefits to replace a portion of wages lost due to inability to work, and benefits for surviving family members in case of death. Employers are responsible for providing workers’ compensation benefits to their