preview

Trumpet By Jackie Kay

Good Essays

“Trumpet, recalling Angela Carter’s The Passion of New Eve, is a fantastic satire of gender confusion, and a moving study of identity and self-discovery”, stated News Statesman. In her Guardian Fiction prize winning award novel - Trumpet, Jackie Kay successfully challenges the notion of traditional heterosexuality assumption. Through the relationship between Joss and Millie, Kay raises a fascinating and ponderable conception that heterosexual relationship should be determined based on how it is perceived by involvers, rather than on biological features. Her hypothesis is well proven via the way Joss represents himself, as well as Millie’s acceptance of his gender role.
To begin with, Joss goes against the social prejudice of how each sex should …show more content…

She accepts Joss’ gender identity as a man and develops a heterosexual attraction to him. Given Joss and Millie’s wedding, it is a traditional marriage with the attendance of the bride and the groom. It conforms to conventional conception of a wedding with no elements of homosexuality or lesbianism. Furthermore, Millie maintains intimate sexual encounter with her husband as an ordinary wife. “I know he wants me…I feel myself being taken away…[…]. He straddles me”. It can be assured that Millie feels a sense of sexual attraction towards a man, her sex life resembles traditional stereotype of sexual intercourse between opposite sex. In their parenthood, both Joss and Millie perform their own gender role in raising Colman. Therefore, via their orthodox relationship, Millie must have regarded Joss as a usual man. Nevertheless, the article ’The Truth is a Thorny Issue’: Lesbian Denial in Jackie Kay’s Trumpet” by Ceri Davies indicates conversely that Millie “was living a lie – the lie that Joss was male – but it was a lie she knew about and her constant denials only force the truth forward”. Davies underscores that Millie is unable to fully acknowledge Joss as a man, but at the same time she cannot recognize herself as a lesbian; therefore, she indulges herself into self-deceit instead of confronting the truth. However, I personally disagree with this viewpoint. Millie’s refusal to contemplate …show more content…

On one hand, their long-stand marriage acquires perfectly almost every characteristics of a straight relationship according to social prejudice. They inheritably express sexual attraction towards other sex, adopt a child, perform conventional gender role – husband and wife, father and mother in family structure. On the other hand, it lacks an element in normal heterosexual relationship, known as sexual intercourse. The fact that Joss is a transvestite but not yet attains masculine features prevents them from ability to bear children. He still owns feminine biological trademarks such as breasts or high voice. Therefore, their relationship poses an unprecedented question to the deep-rooted assumption of heterosexual relationship. Can both sides’ perception of gender identity determine the relationship status instead of solely based on physical features? As a matter of fact, Joss’s biological features impose little influence on his relationship with Millie. They both acknowledge the status of heterosexuality, and even after Joss’s death, Millie maintains her account of the relationship. Therefore, Jackie Kay seemingly disapproves any connection between a man’s anatomical features and his romance relationship. Instead, the relationship status should depend on insiders’ perception of their own gender identity and get recognition in

Get Access