preview

Traumatic Shoulder Dislocations

Decent Essays

GROUP 1 Article Review

QUESTION
• Does arthroscopic treatment of shoulder dislocations result in lower dislocation recurrence rate than non-operative rehabilitation?

CLINICAL BOTTOM LINE
• Arthroscopic Bankart repair of first-time anterior shoulder dislocations significantly reduces the recurrence rate of shoulder dislocations in young athletes when compared to traditional non-operative rehabilitation. SUMMARY OF KEY EVIDENCE (Study Design, Sample, Intervention/Methods, Outcome Measures, Results)
• Study Design – Patients who underwent a traumatic shoulder dislocation were randomized into an operated and non-operated group. Patients were then followed for a minimum of 24 and maximum of 56 months to determine whether a subsequent dislocation or constant instability was experienced.
• Sample – 24 …show more content…

Also, the time at which follow-up occurred was highly variable (subjects were essentially followed until they suffered a subsequent dislocation), which resulted in a ‘self-fulfilling prophecy’ type of situation. The study also doesn’t state whether the same physical therapist supervised each patient’s rehab, and it would be helpful to have a more specific outline of the rehab program as well. Furthermore, the activity level of each patient during the rehab program seemingly wasn’t controlled, and so it’s not far-fetched to believe that the non-op patients were more active with using their shoulder outside of rehab, which could have resulted in their higher rate of dislocations. And lastly, individual perception of what constitutes ‘best’ treatment (i.e. some may believe that surgery is a better form of treatment than no surgery) may have affected motivation during rehab and led to an eventual increased rate of dislocation.

OTHER ELEMENTS
• The paper contained no figures or charts to help better comprehend the results and to make it more visually appealing.

Get Access