preview

Tracy Latimer Unjustified

Good Essays

Latanya Kinlicheenie
ENL 102
Research Paper
November 10, 2012
Tracy Latimer Unjustified Tracy Latimer of Canada was born on November 23, 1980 (Semkiw). On a farm in Saskatchewan, Canada, Tracy lived with her family of six; she was the eldest of her three other siblings (Semkiw). Due to an insufficient amount of oxygen at birth, Tracy was born with Cerebral Palsy. By the age of 12, Tracy had undergone three corrective surgeries in order to “improve her quality of life” (Pickup). When told Tracy needed a fourth surgery, her parents decided she needed to die in order to prevent her from more pain (Pickup). The very night Tracy’s parents were told she needed the fourth surgery, Robert and Laura Latimer admitted they discussed …show more content…

The physicians agreed that dealing with Tracy’s pain required much effort (Rachels). Robert stated, “With the combination of a feeding tube, rods in her back, the leg cut and flopping around and bedsores, how can people say she was a happy little girl?” (Rachels).
Tracy’s pain was exaggerated in the sense that her handicap was a “terminal illness” (Malhotra). Crown, Canada’s government, tried to convince the jury that Tracy had “enjoyed outings… She also responded to visits by her family… her life had value and quality” (News). There are other parents who have children with much severe disabilities yet do not come to the conclusion of ending their child’s life.
Are we all up to determine the value of one’s life, even if it comes down to a disability? Tracy’s parents believed so. In the second trial “Laura collaborated with the defense team to paint Tracy’s life in the worst possible light of unremitting pain and anguish” (Pickup). She also stated that Tracy had made her and Robert “better people” that Tracy showed them “how to love” (Pickup).
What Laura forgot to mention was when her husband was found guilty of raping a 15-year-old girl in 1973. However, the case was overturned by the Judge Noble, very judge who supported Robert Latimer’s decision of killing his daughter 20 years later (Pickup). Prosecutors benefited by declaring other ways of ending Tracy’s pain (White).
Was killing Tracy the easiest way to end

Get Access