preview

Torture In The 8th Amendment

Decent Essays

Solitary confinement can be considered as torture by several people due to the mental pain or suffering that is caused by it. But would solitary confinement be considered an unusual and cruel punishment to the point of violating the eighth amendment? Is torture considered a bad thing? Solitary confinement has been the only choice that the system could think of in order to reprimand those who have already done something wrong. Torture is often used for the purpose of having a positive outcome, which is not a bad thing depending on the situation and its extent. The eighth amendment of the United States Constitution was first introduced by James Madison for the purpose of prohibiting some punishments that are not legal, such as painful and hard labor. This amendment states that punishments must be fair, not cruel, and must have a certain limit. The eighth amendment also prohibits the imposition of excessive bail and excessive fines. For example, an accused must be treated as an innocent person before he or she is proven otherwise. Excessive bail depends on how severe the situations are. Other great examples of the 8th amendment prohibitions are castration, burning at the stake, and quartering. Based on the wording of the amendment, I believe that the use of solitary confinement in the United States does not violate citizens’ eighth amendment rights. A cruel and unusual punishment would be considered grossly disproportionate, which doesn’t exactly concord with solitary

Get Access