preview

To A Locomotive In Winter

Decent Essays

Although both Walt Whitman as well as Emily Dickinson write about trains in the poems “To a Locomotive in Winter” and “I like to See it Lap the Miles, “they both make different uses of tone in their poems. The tones both authors use with the subject are slightly similar, but are also polar opposites in other ways. For example, both Whitman and Dickinson use a tone that is in awe of the power that locomotives possess. Even though they use a similar tone for the power of locomotives, there are some differences with the tone each author uses; Whitman’s work has a sophisticated yet serious tone. Whereas, Dickinson’s poem has a more playful tone. There are many examples of Whitman’s awe of locomotives in “To a Locomotive in Winter.” For example, …show more content…

In Whitman’s “To a Locomotive in Winter”, the first line is, “Thee for my recitative, /” (Gioia 724). His use of the word “recitative” implies a serious if not tragic tone. Yet at the same time, “recitative” also has a feeling of sophistication and grace. According to the OxfordDictionary.com recitative is defined as, “Musical declamation of the kind usual in the narrative and dialogue parts of opera and oratorio, sung in the rhythm of ordinary speech with many words on the same note: singing in recitative.” Therefore, since most operas have a serious if not tragic tone, Whitman is letting the reader know from the first line that the poem will have a serious tone. Now compare that to the first line in Dickinson’s poem, “I like to see it lap the Miles- /” (Gioia 724). Her use of the phrase, “I like to see it lap”, gives the impression of a more fun or playful tone. These differences in tone can be seen again, when comparing line nine of “To a Locomotive in Winter” with line two of “I like to see it lap the Miles”. In line nine Whitman writes, “Thy dese and murky clouds out-belching from thy smoke-stack, /” (Gioia 724). This line is very serious and dark. Yet, line two of Dickinson’s poem, “And lick the Valleys up -/,” shows how playful her tone is, with the connotation of the word

Get Access