Although both Walt Whitman as well as Emily Dickinson write about trains in the poems “To a Locomotive in Winter” and “I like to See it Lap the Miles, “they both make different uses of tone in their poems. The tones both authors use with the subject are slightly similar, but are also polar opposites in other ways. For example, both Whitman and Dickinson use a tone that is in awe of the power that locomotives possess. Even though they use a similar tone for the power of locomotives, there are some differences with the tone each author uses; Whitman’s work has a sophisticated yet serious tone. Whereas, Dickinson’s poem has a more playful tone. There are many examples of Whitman’s awe of locomotives in “To a Locomotive in Winter.” For example, …show more content…
In Whitman’s “To a Locomotive in Winter”, the first line is, “Thee for my recitative, /” (Gioia 724). His use of the word “recitative” implies a serious if not tragic tone. Yet at the same time, “recitative” also has a feeling of sophistication and grace. According to the OxfordDictionary.com recitative is defined as, “Musical declamation of the kind usual in the narrative and dialogue parts of opera and oratorio, sung in the rhythm of ordinary speech with many words on the same note: singing in recitative.” Therefore, since most operas have a serious if not tragic tone, Whitman is letting the reader know from the first line that the poem will have a serious tone. Now compare that to the first line in Dickinson’s poem, “I like to see it lap the Miles- /” (Gioia 724). Her use of the phrase, “I like to see it lap”, gives the impression of a more fun or playful tone. These differences in tone can be seen again, when comparing line nine of “To a Locomotive in Winter” with line two of “I like to see it lap the Miles”. In line nine Whitman writes, “Thy dese and murky clouds out-belching from thy smoke-stack, /” (Gioia 724). This line is very serious and dark. Yet, line two of Dickinson’s poem, “And lick the Valleys up -/,” shows how playful her tone is, with the connotation of the word
To begin with, “To a Locomotive in Winter”, written by Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson’s “I like to see it lap the Miles” are fairly different poems. In “To a Locomotive in Winter”, the author writes about a locomotive and represents it in rather a positive way, using strong and vivid figurative language. While reading the poem, it is apparent that, in general, the speaker while talking about a locomotive implies American technological progress and, obviously, supports it. That is shown through the establishment of a link between science and poetry. Even though “I like to see it lap the Miles” written by Emily Dickinson is also about a locomotive and within the poem, poetry and science are connected, still, the author's approach differs from Whitman's manner. Evidently, it is possible to notice some negative implications. Specifically, the speaker may be afraid of the ongoing technological progress in America and does not support its connotations.
The nineteenth century produced many esteemed authors, including Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman who became two of Americas most popular poets. While vastly different in style and personality, both Dickinson and Whitman relate to many people on an emotional level through their poetry, even in the twenty-first century. The works of poetry by Dickinson and Whitman can be compared on levels of style and form and both writers composed beautiful verses of high quality. Through the following comparisons, it will become apparent how Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman influenced American literature and culture both in similar and diverse ways.
First of all, “O Captain, My Captain” uses extended metaphors, while “Shiloh: A Requiem” does not. Walt Whitman uses many extended metaphors, such as “Captain” referring to Abraham Lincoln, and “fearful trip” meaning the Civil War. This shows how “O Captain, My Captain” uses extended metaphors to give the poem a deeper meaning than it seems. Meanwhile, Herman Melville does not use extended metaphors in his poem. Additionally, “Shiloh: A Requiem” uses personification to convey the mood, and “O Captain, My Captain” does not. For example, Herman Melville uses the phrase “The church so lone” to help convey the mood. This shows personification because loneliness is an emotion, and an inanimate object cannot feel emotions. However, “O Captain, My Captain” does not use personification in the poem. In conclusion, this shows that the two authors use unique means to get their messages
The lives of Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson have many similarities and differences. Here, we will focus on the similarities in their lives in order to bring to attention a correlation between Whitman's poem I Saw in Louisiana a Live-oak Growing and Dickinson's poem # 1510. Both poets wrote during the time of Romanticism, even though Whitman was Dickinson's senior by some eleven years. This however did not influence the way the writing styles of many of their poems coincided.
Have you ever taken something too literal. Poetry can be an enigma. Emily Dickinson, a poet who expresses her life through metaphorical poems. Metaphorical poems are poems that are used to apply something that is not literally relevant but resembles something else. In the first poem, “We Grow Accustomed To The Dark” , Dickinson explains how her everyday life frustrates her and she was ready for a change. In the second poem, “Before I got my eye put out”, indicates how much Dickinson appreciated her sight before it went away. In this essay there will be some explanations on how Emily Dickinson expresses her life experience in an descriptive way.
Dickinson’s tone seems to portray suffering throughout the beginning of her poems, but gradually develops into a more hopeful and optimistic attitude
This provokes the readers' psyche of a lonesome, fragile individual, standing isolated at the end of an dark, treacherous road. This imagery is successfully used to illustrate a portrait of Dickinson, or even the individual reading the piece themselves, as they’re yearning for their new life, which right now is filled with darkness and sorrow. The poem is comprised of five stanzas, each consisting of four lines. The monotonous nature of the poem is nothing gleaming or eye catching, and this is purposely done for the conspicuous fact that sometimes, precious values and things you love are vaporized. With the abandonment of something important, the world does not stop revolving around you and seemingly mold itself for you. It will continue to revolve in the same way it always has for four and half billion years, but now only seeming to be filled with darkness, difficulty and
Emily Dickinson was one of the many famous American poets whose work was published in the 19th century. Her writing style was seen as unconventional due to her use of “dashes and syntactical fragments”(81), which was later edited out by her original publishers. These fragmented statements and dashes were added to give emphasis to certain lines and subjects to get her point across. Even though Emily Dickinson was thought to be a recluse, she wrote descriptive, moving poems on death, religion, and love. Her poems continue to create gripping discussions among scholars on the meaning behind her poems.
Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson’s poetry is very different; however death seems to be a familiar topic amongst both poets. Opposites attract, and you could say the same for Whitman and Dickinson because though they have different writing styles both repeatedly write about death. Once more, although both Whitman and Dickinson have many different feelings about death, they also share many similar feelings about it as well. Although Walt Whitman's poetry is rather long and quite simple and Emily Dickinson's are often short and complex, the theme of death strongly ties their works together.
How does Walt Whitman use figurative language in O Captain! My Captain! to impact the readers. One of the first examples of figurative language in O Captain! my Captain! is an allusion. Two allusions are located on the second line in the first stanza, it says “The ship has weather’d every rack, the prize we sought is won,”. Whitman's uses of allusions are easier to understand if you know history because the ship represents the nation and the prize was the win of the Civil War. Walt Whitman used allusions because if they are constructed well then, the reader may feel more apart of the story and it can capture their attention to keep them interested. Another example of figurative language in the poem is imagery. One use of imagery I found was
In Dickinson’s poem, “Because I could not stop for Death,” there is much impression in the tone, in symbols, and in the use of imagery that exudes creativity. One might undoubtedly agree to an eerie, haunting, if not frightening, tone in Dickinson’s poem. Dickinson uses controlling adjectives—“slowly” and “passed”—to create a tone that seems rather placid. For example, “We slowly drove—He knew no haste / …We passed the School … / We passed the Setting Sun—,” sets a slow, quiet, calm, and dreamy atmosphere (5, 9, 11,
Two of Dickinson’s universal techniques are metaphor and the fresh application of language; both techniques result in powerful images, and can be seen in two of her poems that focus on nature themes, “ A Bird came down the Walk” and “narrow Fellow.” She closes the poem, “ A Bird” with a stanza equating flight through the air with movement through water,
While both are famous trailblazers the two are vastly different. Incipiently, both poets Emily Dickinson and poet Walt Whitman were well known poets one is considered to be one of America's greatest and most original poets, taking definition as her provience and challenging the existing definitions of poetry and a poet’s work, Whitman on the other hand was considered to be a latter day successor to Homer, Shakespeare and Dante, creating monumental work through the chatted praises from body to soul, found beauty and ressourance in death. Both poets come from opposite backgrounds, and while they both share inspirational sources, they do so in distinctive ways. Analyzing two seperate poems from Emily Dickinson and Whitman, I will be comparing and contrasting the poems as I go through
Walt Whitman 's poem, "To a Locomotive in Winter" and Emily Dickinson 's "I Like to See It Lap The Miles" are two different poems about the same subject, the steam engine. Where Whitman uses solely free verse, Dickinson’s poem more closely follows standard writing practices, with very structured line breaks. Another key difference in these works is the speech they use; Whitman uses "old English" laden with thee and thy, whereas Dickinson uses fairly modern terminology. Whitman describes the elegant and powerful grandeur of the locomotive from the shining brass and steel to the twinkling of the wheels. Dickinson describes the arrogance and nuisance of it as she imagines it staring down upon the
In his first anthology of poems entitled “Song of Myself”, Walt Whitman reveals some of his views on democracy through the use of symbolism and free verse poetry. His use of symbolism and free verse poetry creates indeterminacy, giving the reader hints rather than answers about the nature of the poem. In the sixth part of “Song of Myself”, a child asks the narrator of the poem, “What is the grass?” (Whitman). Instead of simply giving an answer, the narrator cannot make up his mind, and stumbles on how to explain the grass to the child. Through the use of specific symbolisms, Whitman, as the narrator, explicates his views while remaining under the façade of explaining grass to the child. The views Whitman conveys remain indeterminate and