preview

Ting

Better Essays

Mapping the Man behind the Qing-period Garden The symposium, “Artful Retreat: Garden Culture of the Qing Dynasty”, jointly organized by the Peabody Essex Museum and Harvard University and held on 12-13 November 2010, reveals Qianlong’s emotional relationships to the Qing gardens. Gathering scholars from Australia, China, Europe, and the United States, it provides an exceptional opportunity for ten scholars, such as Hui Zou (Professor of Architecture at the University of Florida) and Mark Elliott (Professor of Chinese and Inner Asian History in the Department of East Asian Languages and Civilizations at Harvard University), to share their perspectives on the artistic, political, historical, and economic aspects of the Qing-period garden culture. …show more content…

Berliner’s article, however, is less compelling than these. In order to explain the blend of the artifact and the natural settings in the Liubei Ting (流杯亭), she gives an example of a Qianlong-period vase with different designs and glazes, asserting that Qianlong liked contrast and preferred to amalgamate different design elements together. The evidence, yet, is not solid enough to support this argument. First, the lecturer does not show her evidence objectively, because she only talks about the feature of a specific vase, rather than a general type. The type of vase that shows sharp contrast between glaze colors is the wucai (五彩) ware, developing from the sancai (三彩) technique in the Tang dynasty. Apart from the mixed-color vases, there were a lot of other categories of vases in the Qianlong period. One dominant type is the blue and white ware. Porcelains with famille rose overglaze enamel decoration were also popular. This kind has the harmonious combination of colors of green, yellow, black, and rose with blurry edges between colors. Also, these types of porcelain often have auspicious themes. For instance, the Blue and White Vase of Soft-Paste Porcelain with a Lion and an Eagle (Fig. 2) depicts a theme of longevity and happiness. Presenting unity in both the subject matters and the glaze colors, these vases do not suggest contrast. Instead of rushing into the conclusion that most Qianlong-period vases show contrasts in design, the speaker should have taken other types of vases into account. Therefore, it cannot persuasively support the argument against the emperor’s propensity for implementing different elements in design. Neither could it justify Qianlong’s conscious choice of integrating the abstract manmade water channel into the realistic natural landscape

Get Access