preview

The Voyage Of James Caird Analysis

Decent Essays

Many accidents that occur in the wilderness happen because of people’s lack of good decisions, and the cost of the rescue can put other people’s lives in danger. Making unnecessary risks to save someone in a situation that never had to happen is why people should be held accountable for their actions in a life-or-death situation. However, many other people think that they shouldn’t be held accountable. Both perspectives think that their argument is right, but the facts are clear: people should be held accountable for their actions, you should be responsible for what you choose to do. Most people who end up in a life-or-death situations were because they weren’t prepared, they should be held accountable for going into a situation without having …show more content…

For example, in “To Build a Fire” paragraph 24 it says “perhaps the old-timer in Sulphur Creek was right. If he had only had a trail mate, he would have been in no danger now.” In other words, the man was told not to travel alone and still did, by his situation he realized he should have. Also in “The Voyage of James Caird” paragraph 1 it says “the Caird’s crew ran into an old enemy, the pack.” To explain, the crew ran into this obstacle before, but still went against it again, not listening to warning got them into life-or-death situation. Also, in “Survival is Your Own Responsibility” paragraph 4 it states “many times I have tried to warn…”. In other words travelers have been warned multiple times and still end up in a life-or-death situation., they haven’t cluelessly walked into a …show more content…

For example, In “To Build a Fire” it says “Now the tree which he had done this carried a weight of snow on its boughs” In other words, The man at one point built his fire under a snow covered tree, which led to his fire being buried by the falling snow. The man had been already close to freezing and he was not making good decisions, making his situation worse. He should be held accountable because at that certain moment, the man had a chance to make fire and keep warm in a better location, but he decided to make it in a bad area causing him to continually freeze. Also, in “Survival Is Your Own Responsibility” it says “Errors in judgment are educational if they send the right message- that turning around at the right time or opting not to go on are the decisions that will save your life again and again… to some degree we have come to see it as a quest instead of a warning”. In other words, it means that our decisions can sometimes lead to life or death in that situation. What we decide to do in a situation is what we should be responsible for because we choose which path we want to take whether it’s right or wrong. In “The Voyage of James Caird” the crew were in a life-or-death situation when caught

Get Access