preview

The Theme Of Loyalty And Justice In Montana 1948

Good Essays

Just like in the book Montana 1948, I would like to write to you about how human nature is explained through loyalty and justice. As we have gone to school together for seven years, I would like to show you how the faults of our human nature can be explained through what has happened in Montana 1948. Throughout the book, the faults of human nature are seen as loyalty outweighs justice as seen through Frank molesting Native American girls. His loyalty to his brother, Frank, and his prejudice towards Native Americans questions the belief of justice. He has received all his power from his parents, so it is nearly impossible for him to go against his family. However, Wes is stuck between his father, a powerful, intimidating man and his wife, …show more content…

Whatever he may do, it may be a catastrophic decision. Like us today, Wes is stuck between the past versus the present, loyalty versus justice, and the fear that takes over when the decision is finally made. Unlike in Montana 1948, we must make decisions based on our morals, justice, fearing nothing. In the book, Wes protected Frank’s immoral behaviors surrounding the Native American women by justifying that it could not happen since you could not prove anything that Frank had done. However, there was proof by the Native Americans. However, instilled by `his loyalty to his prejudice father, Julian, Wes could not trust or believe the beliefs of the Native Americans. Wes never feared the wrath of Gail, who supported the Native Americans, since the power he received came from Julian. This power that he received, the loyalty he had, was overpowering justice. Dave …show more content…

After Wes had found Frank guilty of murder, Wes decided to lock Frank up in a bathroom in the basement of Wes’s house. However, although Wes feels that he has found Frank guilty,the father of Wes, Julian, believes that Wes should not lock his brother, Frank, up. Trying to get Frank out of Wes’s basement, Julian sends his foreman in order to get Frank. However, they were not successful and Frank remained locked up in the basement. Julian and Wes were now at odds with each other. The past and the present were becoming two opposites. On one side was loyalty, and on the other was justice. Suddenly one night, the unimaginable happened when Wes,Gail,and David heard Frank smashing jars in the basement,” That’s just what he wants. No,let him get it out of his system. He’ll run out of jars eventually.”p.147 In this quote, Wes is saying that Frank wants to break the jars. For me, the jars symbolize loyalty and how the Hayden family is screwed tight to the jars, symbolizing the closeness of the family. Wes is saying that he can break the jars, since he will eventually run out of jars. The breaking of the jars in the middle of the night fears Gail, however it does nothing to Wes. Wes believes that since the jars are breaking , they have to stop symbolizing how the family is crumbling, but the crumbling in going to stop. In other words, the fear, the crumbling, will lead to change. Mark, I remember when the nurse’s son was

Get Access