preview

The Soloist

Decent Essays

From the beginning of his story, John Nash is shown to be different than most people. The viewer is shown that his behavior is erratic, illustrated in the scene where he loses in a game of Othello and stumbles away in a frenzy, and awkward, shown in many of his social interactions. This of course amplifies when it is revealed that he is schizophrenic. John is seen as absolutely mad, interacting with his delusions, following conspiracies in newspapers, and having meetings with secret government organizations. The viewer sees this and thinks of Nash and his condition as horrifying, but at the same time an endowment. John is portrayed as extremely bright and has the capacity to do amazing things in the field of mathematics. This juxtaposes the …show more content…

This choice already alienates the viewer from the perspective of schizophrenia in a way that I feel places A Beautiful Mind above The Soloist. We see that initially Steve Lopez is on the hunt for a story and while brainstorming he meets Nathaniel in a park. Nathaniel’s attire is unconventional to say the least. He wears a safety vest with scribbles all over and carts around garbage; his violin only has two strings and his speech seems like a never ending rambling. Statistics from Schitozphrenia.com say, “Approximately 200,000 individuals with schizophrenia or manic-depressive (bipolar disorder) illness are homeless, constituting one-third of the approximately 600,000 homeless population (total homeless population statistic based on data from Department of Health and Human Services).” Meaning that one out of every three homeless people could have the same condition as Nathaniel. While both movies portray their schizophrenic protagonists as being extremely talented, in The Soloist Nathaniel’s talent is seen more as a spectacle. Lopez does not approach Nathaniel as a person with a story to tell, but more as a story with a person attached to it. Their first encounter is solely for the purpose of creating an article that will appeal to the masses. Lopez states on the phone with Nathaniel’s sister that he wants to write a story about him, “Because he’s interesting.” To the viewer Nathaniel is a spectacle instead of an artist. He follows the “Super Crip” model outlined in Representing Disability in an Ableist World. The book states, “Insensitivity and stubborn ignorance characterize much press coverage of disability related news.” Nathaniel is shown as a spectacle throughout the movie, most notably in the scene where at his recital and is not given a suit or a proper set up. The scoffs and laughter of

Get Access