In W.W. Jacobs' classic short story, "The Monkey's Paw," the character of Herbert White plays a crucial role in the unfolding tragedy. Through his choices and actions, Herbert sets in motion a series of events that lead to the devastating consequences experienced by the White family. Textual evidence reveals Herbert's role as a catalyst for the misfortune that befalls the family, emphasizing the importance of responsibility and caution when dealing with supernatural forces. Herbert's dismissive attitude towards the monkey's paw sets the stage for the family's downfall. When Sergeant-Major Morris introduces the mystical talisman, Herbert mocks the idea of three wishes, declaring, "Well, don't break into the money before I come back" (Jacobs). This casual remark demonstrates Herbert's lack of respect for the potentially dangerous powers of the paw, laying the foundation for the tragedy that follows. …show more content…
He overlooks the potential consequences of tampering with fate and fails to consider the source and legitimacy of the money. The narrator remarks, "The following night, things were, and it might be, expected to be worse" (Jacobs). The ominous tone suggests that Herbert's wish is not without its perils, and his lack of caution is a direct contributing factor to the impending disaster. The sudden and tragic death of Herbert in a workplace accident is a direct result of his wish for wealth. The narrator notes, "He was caught in the machinery" (Jacobs), linking the unexpected death explicitly to the financial windfall Herbert wished for. This turn of events underscores the consequences of Herbert's choices, as his desire for material gain leads to irreversible tragedy for himself and his
The supernatural’s existence has been debated for many centuries now. It is even debated in the Bible. Mark Twain tries to settle the debate once and for all in A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court using a vast variety of characters. While magic symbolizes a lot in this novel, Twain uses it to compare Sandy and Hank. Hank was unable to tell anyone about the future or he would be killed for using black magic.
When Mr. White does not want to wish Herbert back to life, he is scared of the monkey’s paw and scared to change fate
There are many reasons that shows Herbert was responsible for his death. For example on page 36, Herbert stated “If only you cleared the house you might be happy. This shows that Herbert could have cause this upon himself, because if Mr.White would have made a wish for the house to be more clear or clean , this could have
It is shown that Herbert also believes this concept when he says, “I think every man, for his own self-respect, should earn what he lives on.” (Vonnegut, 68). Yet as previously stated, Herbert learned all of his virtues from his
“It seems to me I’ve got all I want.” “If you only cleared the house, you’d be quite happy, wouldn’t you!” said Herbert, with his hand on his shoulder. “Well, wish for two hundred pounds, then, that’ll just do it.”... ”I wish for two hundred pounds,” said the old man distinctly...
The story begins on a dark story night, as the three members of the White family were relaxing and waiting for someone on their cozy home. Herbert White and his father are playing a game of chess. As the game comes to an end with Herbert as a winner, a family friend Sergeant- Major Morris came over for a visit. They welcome him with a whisky, as he was telling stories about his exploit abroad. Mr. White is interested in his stories and eventually returned to the subject, the monkey's paw that Morris mentioned earlier. Morris tries to put him off, but it only excites the Whites.
“The Monkey’s Paw” starts in a middle class cottage located in England. The White family invited a friend over for dinner. Randall White asked Sergeant Major Morris about the “Monkey’s Paw”. Sergeant Major Morris doesn’t really appreciate the fact that Randall White brings up the “Monkey’s Paw”. The Monkey’s Paw was not a blessing, it was a curse. Sergeant Major Morris tells Randall that the old talisman was cursed by an wise fakir. The Whites do not believe Sergeant Major Morris one bit. They think he is joking with them, but in reality Sergeant Morris is right all along. Three men get the chance to grant three wishes, but with every wish there are consequences to pay. Sergeant Major Morris and another man received their wishes, but for the first man, death came his way. Still fond of the idea of getting three free wishes, Randall did not mind the
The story’s that we’re going to be comparing and contrasting is The Monkey’s Paw and The Third Wish. The author of The Monkey’s Paw is W.W. Jacobs and the author of The Third Wish is Joan Aiken. What I feel is important about this is almost everything. These two stories are okay and they have a good mood throughout the entire story. My favorite one out these two is The Third Wish. The characters in the Monkey’s Paw are Mr. Mrs. White, the character in the Third Wish is Mr. Peters
This is an important detail to include in the film and text because it shows just how powerful the paw is, and how Herbert's personality/sarcasm towards the wish his father made inevitably led to his death. Another example included in the
“The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W. Jacobs is about a suspicious man named Sergeant Major Morris who seems like a very suspicious person and comes to the Whites’ home with a magical Monkey's Paw that grants wishes for them. He also comes to deliver some news that may not be the best of news. The theme in “The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W. Jacobs is Be happy with what you have; don’t always strive for something that you aren’t capable of getting because it might not always be good! The following piece of evidence shows that Herbert was thinking that his parents, the White’s, did not really want him anymore.
The readers experience is made greater by exploring these leading characters actions and emotions. Herbert explores concepts before his time of genetic manipulation,
Another reason why I think Mr. White is responsible for Herbert’s death is because in the story Mr. White
Willy’s struggle with the machines such as his car, the refrigerator, and Howard’s tape recorder suggest that he cannot face reality. Rather than fixing the car he refuses to pay the mechanic because he owes too much money. Willy blames “manufacture of the car” (1.314) instead of realizing that it is his fault for getting in a car accident. Willy cannot face the reality that things are changing and need to be done.
spiritual beliefs in this book and also by the imaginary things Herbert is introducing to us. The
“Why we’re going to be rich, and famous and happy. Wish to be an emperor, Father, to begin with; then you can’t be henpecked.” Herbert manipulates Mr.White into making a wish. Unfortunately, Mr.White does and Mr.White’s first wish terminates the life of his own son. “Well, I don’t see the money….and I bet I never shall.”