preview

The Monkey's Paw Essay

Decent Essays

In the short story, “The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W Jacobs, the main character’s son dies due to a mishap at his work. They get this monkey paw and it grants them three wishes. Mr. (Herbert’s dad) and Mrs. White (Herbert’s mom) makes the second wish to bring Herbert back, which is when the knocking started. Mr. White then makes the third wish, which is unknown to us, the reader, and the knocking then stops. Question is, was Herbert at the door and in what form was he in? Herbert was at the door and he was in the form of a spirit. Mrs. White was talking to Mr. White about using their second wish to bring Herbert back to life. But Mr. White didn’t want that. Here is what he said, “He’s been dead ten days, and besides he - I would not tell you else, but - I could only recognize him by his clothing. …show more content…

Herbert has been dead for 10 days when Mrs.White wanted to bring him back to life. If he were to be brought back to life you can highly assume that he wouldn’t look the same or even be the same person as he was before he died. This is why Mr. White didn’t want to have Hebert back. Typically, a body starts to decompose 24 hours after death and if Herbert would come back to life, he wouldn’t have been a normal human being like he was before he died. Also, there was knocking at the front door after Mrs. White made the second wish. As there was knocking, Mr. White said, “For God’s sake, don’t let it in, cried the old man trembling.” (Jacobs 8). Mr. White didn’t want to open the door because he thought it wasn’t Herbert. He thought it would be the ghost/spirit of Herbert no matter how much his wife wanted Herbert to come in. Also, Mr. White called whatever was at the door a “it” which implies that it wasn’t Herbert himself at the door, or at least Mr.White didn’t think so. Usually, when something is called an “it”, it most likely indicates that it is not a person, it’s more of a

Get Access