When I look at mythology during the past and present I can find a lot of similarities in the
base components of these stories. Joseph John Campbell was an American mythologist, writer
and lecture. I am instructed by a lot of his thoughts when thinking about myth stories. As Dr.
Joseph Campbell pointed out in his theory of the monomyth, all the myths that have withstood
the test of time for thousands of years are based on a similar foundation. This foundation is
explored in his book The Hero with a Thousand Faces where he describes the theory in this
quote “A hero ventures forth from the world of common day into a region of supernatural
wonder: fabulous forces are there encountered and a decisive victory is won: the hero comes
back from this mysterious adventure with the power to bestow boons on his fellow man.” With
the theory of a monomyth summarized in these lines I will apply its idea in my comparison and
contrast the stories of Greek mythological hero Heracles to the modern day super hero
Superman. This paper will then talks about whether both characters have influenced societal
norms on the perception of heroes and the many attributes they possess. At the end I conclude
that they have influenced our modern day ideal of heroism and what people usually expect a hero
to be like.
Before analyzing the background stories of our two characters we must explain what
exactly we believe a hero is. A hero is a person, typically a man, who is admired
As time goes on and new generations come about, many of the ideals of former generations seem to become irrelevant. Scott LaBarge, a professor of philosophy, elaborates on this idea and others in his essay. “Why Heroes Are Important” is LaBarge’s pursuit to persuade others of his idea of heroes in today’s society. He claims that many of our youth do not know what a proper hero is and that former generations should be educating them. LaBarge begins his persuasion by describing his personal experience and credibility; then, he briefly describes the history of heroes to tie in his opinion on the definition; finally, he uses Aristotle’s idea of Kairos to explain how his opinion proves true according to current events.
Sacrifice for the greater good is the natural inclination for heroes and protagonists in stories; however, in order to subsidize and materialize the profits for forfeiting one's humanity which is a drastic step towards lowering one's abilities and the perception other people have of that individual. A false hero practices charisma, a desire to succeed and the need to be placed on a pedestal adorned by arbitrary individuals. These practices serve as the root for this “Hero” to forward his ideas on those closest to him, even if those close individuals are regarded as rational and clear-minded. These followers hurl themselves at the whims of the “Hero” willing to sacrifice their dreams and aspirations for the “Heroes” own gratification and elation.
Throughout history the traditional heroic elements have changed because of our society. Although elements of a hero have changed there are also certain characteristics of a hero that stays the same, such as a hero’s character and courage. This can be seen through Beowulf , “ The Epic and the Epic Hero,”and the movie “The 13th Warrior.”
For example, some people argue that Bond is perceived as the anti-hero. This interpretation would make sense because some people believe that Bond lacks conventional heroic attributes. He often uses fancy weapons, like a handgun that recognizes his palm print, and different specialized methods of transportation. In addition, his character, often drinking, sexualized, and in the beginning weak, is seen as having non-heroic characteristics. However, this view is ultimately weakened by not acknowledging the validity of Campbell’s research on the hero journey.
Sacrifice for the greater good is the natural inclination for heroes and protagonists in stories; however, in order to subsidize and materialize the profits for forfeiting one's humanity which is a drastic step towards lowering one's abilities and the perception other people have of that individual. A false hero practices charisma, a desire to succeed and the need to be placed on a pedestal adorned by arbitrary individuals. These practices serve as the root for this “Hero” to forward his ideas on those closest to him, even if those close individuals are regarded as rational and clear-minded. These followers hurl themselves at the whims of the “Hero” willing to sacrifice their dreams and aspirations for the the “Heroes” own gratification and
In 1949, Joseph Campbell published his book “The Hero with a Thousand Faces.” It details his theory of the “monomyth,” a theory that illustrates how many heroic mythological stories have similar outlines and archetypes. During his discussion of the second chapter of the monomyth, Campbell says that the monomyth can “serve as a general pattern for men and women” in their everyday lives (121). In many circumstances, comparisons can be made between normal situations throughout life and the monomyth. When a challenge of task is encountered in life, it can be analyzed under the three main stages of the monomyth: the departure, the initiation, and the return.
When the average person thinks of mythology, they are most likely to think about archaic stories about gods and heroes with fantastic powers and histories. While living in our technologically advanced time period, these myths that we learn about were once common teachings in ancient lands used to explain natural phenomenon and teach moral standards to people. As fantastic as the stories of myth sound like, many people dismiss them and assume these stories of fantasy no longer play a role in out modern-day lives. What most people do not realize, however, is that many aspects of myth are still involved with the
“A hero ventures forth from the world of common day into a region of supernatural wonder: fabulous
The idea of heroismhas been traced back to centuries of years throughout history. Greek Mythology is the father of this concept of heroism and this concept has continued to grow and develop through stories, writings, and films over the years. Humans have always been intrigued with the idea of heroism which is why many movies, books, and stories are written after this very idea. In Linda Seger’s “Creating the Myth”, she argues there are 10-points into creating every “hero myth”, using Luke Skywalker in Star Wars as her hero myth example; in the film Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, Harry follows Seger’s 10-point system of creating a
The hero has survived death, overcome his greatest fear and now earns the reward he sought.
Heroes are those who have gone above what the average person would do to ensure the welfare of others. Natural disasters, terrorism, poverty, and war are some of the many things that destroy and end people’s lives. Throughout history, many people have made a difference. However, as history progresses, what we consider to be socially normal changes along with our definition of a hero. In Ancient Greece, Theseus, Hercules, and Perseus were considered heroes, but today only Theseus and Perseus would be considered heroes because Hercules would be shunned by society.
When looking at the myths between various ancient cultures, distinct similarities appear between motifs and symbols of their stories. It is often speculated why these characteristics remain consistent despite differences in time, location, culture and beliefs. Looking at the similarities between Greek, Aztec, and Norse mythology can perhaps shed some light on this mystery. All three myths feature an apocalyptic event that starts a new life cycle, an element of sacrifice to retain order, and the death and rebirth of a god. The theory of James Frazer best explains why these similarities exist, possibly bringing a new perspective into the study of ancient mythology.
To begin, Linda Seger’s article demonstrates how the idea of a hero is universal and is defined by their journey, which is incorrect because other cultures might define a hero as something else. In her article, she tries using ten stages of how a hero is sometimes just an ordinary person. Who then takes in order
The author uses the story of the Buddha to state the journey a hero has to go through to achieve their powers/ability. The hero leaves his environment, learns or develops, and then returns to spread what he loved. All hero stories follow the same guidelines.
Heroes are prevalent in everyone’s life. Whether someone’s hero is a living person or a fabled character from a movie, everybody has come into contact with some sort of hero. In fact, the concept of heroes has existed for hundreds of years, dating all the way back to Ancient Greece. Over time, heroes have drastically changed. As society has evolved, our heroes have evolved with it. Their goals and motivations have changed to coincide with the views of modern society. Modern day heroes have less selfish motives, better qualities, and are portrayed differently than ancient heroes.