preview

The Grand Inquisitor Poem Analysis

Decent Essays

The Grand Solution for the Grand Inquisitor “Here the devil is struggling with God, and the battlefield is the human heart,” says Dostoevsky through Dmitri. In the book, The Brothers Karamazov, written by Fyodor Dostoevsky, Ivan and Alyosha seem to represent the Karamazov Heart, as they argue upon God’s theodicy. Ivan announces to Alyosha that he wishes to recite a poem that he memorized called, The Grand Inquisitor, in order to justify his rebellion towards God. Here, I will give a general summary and analysis of the text, and finally, critique Ivan’s philosophical ideas. The poem takes place during the 16th Century in Spain, at the time of the inquisition. Jesus appears, and goes to the Seville Cathedral, were he finds a dead girl in a white coffin. Jesus raises the girl from the dead, and people are amazed. However, the Inquisitor wasn’t happy with what he saw, and ordered his guards to seize Christ. Christ was then taken to a prison, and later, the Grand Inquisitor appears to …show more content…

The Grand Inquisitor states that Christ could have come down from the cross when people told him, “He saved others; himself he cannot save. If he be the King of Israel, let him now come down from the cross, and we will believe him.” However, Christ chose not to do so because he didn’t want people to be enslaved by a miracle. Again, the Inquisitor states that the freedom given to man by God is too tough a burden, especially if we are to mimic Christ. True, thousands of people may be able to do it, but they are gods, sons of the most high, whereas others are left for damnation. Hence the question is raised. “Can it be that you indeed came only to the chosen ones and for the chosen ones?” But how is it that a good God lets his millions of his people die all in the name of freedom. Wouldn’t it be his fault for giving man freedom, for it is by freedom that man condemns himself. Hence, Christ should of accepted the second offer by The

Get Access