The Giver Punishment Analysis

Jonas’ has had a variety of interesting experiences throughout the book. The Giver by Lois Lowry is about Jonas and he goes through many changes in his life with some help from the Giver. Jonas’ experiences develop a theme over the course of The Giver by teaching the reader for every action there is a consequence. Although some readers may believe that there will not be a consequence, Jonas’ experiences show that there are good and bad consequences for everything you do.

This shows that pain, suffering, and the real world should not be forced onto one person because it does not work and the one person that does have to face all of the truth will not believe that it is right. Another reason that connects to not only one person should face suffering and sorrow shown in The Giver is when Jonas thinks about how he was the only person that had to go through what was actually happening and wanted to tell others what was actually happening. For example, the author wrote,"They were satisfied with their lives which had none of the vibrance his own was taking on. And he was angry at himself, that he could not change that for them. "(Lois Lowry, 13).This explains that with throwing all of sorrow and pain on to one person makes them think that they should help others that don't get to experience the truth but they cant making

In the novel, The Giver, people have been stripped of powerful and potent emotions such as love to match the strict guild lines of their community. Lowis Lowery illustrates through the Transition of Jonas, how human emotions are necessary to build a character with moral and ethical values and promote a life worth living fully. In Jonas community people do not understand emotion or pain because life is so controlled and predictable.

“Jonas has not been assigned,” She informed the crowd, and his heart sank. Then she went on. “Jonas has been selected.” The quote pertained to this story due to the significance that Jonas had differentiated from his peers that had their differences acknowledged by the Elders themselves, each with their own desires within a career. The quote influenced Jonas his decisions within the chapters beyond the quote within the story, nevertheless brought Jonas his viewpoint of the situation and his decision into escaping from the community with Gabe to journey off Elsewhere. For example, Gabe had been planned for release the same day Jonas had escaped from the community, due to Jonas’ significant viewpoints he couldn’t bare the loss of Gabe, especially since he would be the only few to discover the true meaning behind being “released.” In the end of “The Giver,” Jonas and Gabriel had hallucinated while freezing to death because of the wild berries, the memories, and the physical limits of his human body.

Imagine stepping up on a stage in front of the whole city, and learning that being assigned the most rare assignment in the city, is an honor, but learning it involves pain. Would people find it as an honor, or a punishment? It is an honor for Jonas to be chosen as the Receiver because he learns things he has never known before, the community realizes Jonas has a very honorable assignment, and it’s very rare and honorable.

In the novel, Jonas says he is strong enough for his training after he receives his first memory of war and continues with his receiving. A text-to-text connection I made when I was reading The Giver is to Anthem, by Ayn Rand. Both of these societies are meant to be perfect, but are

Imagine a world with no feelings, no color, no choice; a world where individuality and freedom are exchanged for security and sameness. This type of world is a reality for Jonas, the protagonist in Lois Lowry’s The Giver. After being assigned the next Receiver of Memories in the community, where he has the capacity to see beyond. As he begins his works, he gains wisdom and through that wisdom, learned that protecting the community from the memories, their lives lacked understanding and feelings. Jonas goes on an archetypal hero’s journey and chooses to risk everything to restore memories and wisdom to everyone in the community. Throughout this novel, Jonas is represented as a hero considering he demonstrates integrity despite living in a

Because this title comes with a lifetime of pain, it is seen as the most respected position in the community. Jonas begins to learn what life was like before they all turned to sameness, and he enjoys this old world. His mentor, The Giver, is the one who gives him the memories of the past world, which either pain him or bring him immense joy. This journey of self-discovery and overcoming obstacles will make any reader analyze themselves.

As Lois Lowry once said, “Be proud of your pain, for you are stronger than those with none.” In her book The Giver, Lowry writes about pain but in some ways happiness through it. After one apprentice, The Giver has reasons for making Jonas’s training different than Rosemary’s. When Jonas is selected as the new Receiver, The Giver has to change how his training will go because of his feelings. The Giver gradually gives Jonas painful memories.

“The worst part of holding the memories is not the pain. It’s the loneliness of it. Memories need to be shared. (Lowry, Goodreads). In other words it’s saying the pain Jonas is feeling is mental and emotional but not physical. The giver is making Jonas feel these memories and they're coming back to his head. And by sharing memories it lets you get help or makes you feel good because people can help you. My Thesis is comparing and contrasting modern day to the Giver.

An anonymous author exclaimed “I’d rather be physically hurt than emotionally; because you can put a bandaid on your finger… but you can’t put one on your heart.” The main idea of The Giver, a dystopian novel by Lois Lowry, is about a young boy named Jonas who finds out that being born in a utopian society isn’t the best achievement, when he learns the cycle and all about the dreadful society around him. Therefore, Jonas experiences horrible things about his society and in his assignment like loneliness, isolation, horrible memories, and release. Thus, after all he has struggled just as a 12 year boy he is devastated and this shows that his assignment is actually felt like a huge punishment, yet he still gets knowledge from all the horrible memories. To begin

, by Lois Lowry,Jonas is selected to be the new receiver in his community. This position is a punishment. Jonas lives in a world where there is no emotions and jonas has to receive memories both good and bad. The main reasons why Jonas is receiving a punishment will be shown before he was receiver, while he was receiver, and after he was the receiver.

Training has to take place before the person actually takes on the job. Jonas’ mentor is The Giver, and The Giver is the lame duck in this case because once the training is done he becomes an official elder. The Giver passes on all sorts of memories to Jonas, and some are so excruciating that there are mental scars instead of physical. Jonas battles himself to either overcome that pain or give into it, and if he gives in. That means; no more Jonas.

The Giver shows us that love is an essential part to this world. The Giver shows Jonas the memory of pain and suffering and reacted in a way that made him upset, expressing love to Jonas as well as regret. Jonas was “no longer enjoying the freedom but instead, terrified…”(137). The Giver knows what Jonas is experiencing and regrets it although it is what he is told to do. The Giver took a liking to Jonas but couldn’t bare to watch him in pain. Jonas sacrificed his own comfort so the Giver could be relieved of these memories for himself. These same memories were given to the Giver because it was his job. The Giver of each generation feels love toward the new Receiver because the Giver knows what pain is like. Love is essential in this moment, especially for Jonas, because he needs a person to help him to start a new, more utopian society. People show love by sacrificing themselves for

First, Jonas was given pain earlier than Rosemary. Second, Jonas was given physical pain, whereas Rosemary received emotional pain. Third, because Rosemary was the Giver’s daughter, he failed to train her. And fourth, the Giver trained Jonas and rosemary differently because of his emotional attachments to Rosemary. These issues will be elaborated on in the next few paragraphs. The Giver made several changes to the way he trained Jonas after he failed to train Rosemary.