preview

Essay about The Divided Self Commentary

Better Essays

‘The Divided Self’ by R. D. Laing Commentary In ‘The Divided Self’, Laing examines schizoid and schizophrenic people and attempts to make their situation more understandable in existential terms. In order to understand Laing’s work, a person must first understand the concept of existential phenomenology, in which a person is characterized by his way of being-in-the-world. It involves the way he reacts to his environment and himself as a part of his world. It must also be mentioned that a person can not interact with the world, without having relatedness to others in the world. Part One Laing begins by stating that a schizoid is one that is divided into different parts, between himself and his world, and within his own …show more content…

The psychiatrist’s personal opinions regarding the patient are not important, and so therefore it’s best that a professional manner when dealing with patients is taken. Looking at an example of one of Kraepelin’s patients who was showing ‘signs’ of catatonic excitement, we come back to the picture of the vase or two faces. Depending on which way this behaviour is viewed; it is possible to see that either this was simply another sign of his disease, or that he wanted to confirm his own existence, rather than being treated and tested as an object. It is impossible not to impose out own interpretations of the patient’s actions, no matter if one tries to be more objective, to see more signs of disease, or to view his actions as a movement of muscles. Once the psychiatrist has developed a relationship with the patient, it is impossible to be entirely neutral. The way the patient and his actions are interpreted is a key component. Clinical psychiatry can be compared to the analysis of ancient documents, in the sense that instead of formally analyzing the structure, style and other linguistic traits, the patient’s speech and behaviour is closely scrutinized. By knowing the patient’s history, as with early documents, it may be easier to understand the patient’s position, and therefore allow the psychiatrist

Get Access