preview

The Departed Comparison

Decent Essays

The movies Infernal Affairs (2002, directed by Andrew Lau) and The Departed (2006, directed by Martin Scorsese), the latter being an adaptation of the former, are surprisingly similar films overall. The discrepancies between the two motion pictures are only easily seen when analyzing the difference in the narrative, plot and cinematography used within each film, while taking into account the influences of the differing cultures that the two films were created in (i.e. location of creation). Due to the differing locales: China (Hong Kong) for Infernal Affairs and the United States (Boston) for The Departed, the unique and different cultures influenced the modification that took place in the adaptation from the former into the latter. The difference …show more content…

Romance, as seen in Infernal Affairs and The Departed, are highly different. In the former, it is barely touched at all and most love interests are chaste whereas in the latter it is much more explicit. Throughout The Departed, it is apparent that sexuality goes hand in hand with masculinity: as expressed by Sullivan mocking the firemen for being gay when the police department loses to a football game. Most insults and threats invariably involve sexual references unlike Infernal Affairs. One interesting thing to analyze between the two films, is the psychological stress that is shown and acted out by the characters in the films. While The Departed is a longer film, it is slightly less psychologically nuanced than Infernal Affairs. Sullivan is not shown as truly evil, but his speculations are never really scrutinized. Costigan is easily seen conflicted, but that stems from his fear of being discovered and killed. In Infernal Affairs, it is somewhat clear that both Lau and Chen are feeling a disconnection between their internal and external self, stemming from their involvement in spying. The borderline between a police officer and a triad member becomes easier to cross. This shows the influence of culture on the overall film, and the subsequent narrative, plot and use of cinematic

Get Access