preview

The Continuing Immigration Debate Summary

Decent Essays

Mark Rosenblum, “US IMMIGRATION POLICY SINCE 9/11” Mark Rosenblum’s “U.S Immigration Policy Since 9/11” does not provide an argument but rather he describes “challenges, and identifies questions central to the future of the U.S immigration debate. Overall, it seems that prior to 9/11 it seemed migration negotiations were stalled every time. Whether this was done purposely or is merely a coincidence is my concern.
Rosenblum states that migration negotiations going well until 2001, post-9/11 period, when “migration negotiations with Mexico collapsed” (1). Rosenblum goes on to illustrate how policy changed after 9/11, resulting in “five sweeping antiterrorism measures” that fall into three groups (4). No matter which category the measures fall …show more content…

Martin describes a country that is supposed to welcome immigrants with open arms and how the United States has now closed its front door on immigrants. Overall, Martin seems to be pro-immigration. The paper was informative and provided insight on the stalled construction of policy.
Monica Varsanyi, “Taking Local Control: Immigration Policy Activism in U.S. Cities” Monica Versanyi’s, “Taking Local Control: Immigration Policy Activism in U.S. Cities” also addresses immigration policy. However, Versanyi focuses on the growing strains between local, state, and federal government. Furthermore, Versanyi illustrates how the U.S. federal government has complete control over immigration.

Angela Garcia, “Hidden in Plain …show more content…

Garcia uses surveys to examine various aspects of immigration policy, behavior, and settlement. It is refreshing to hear that immigrants do not let policy influence their destination of settlement. I would imagine that policy would have an immense impact on dynamics such as this. In addition, it was not surprising that economic and social factors “more prominently shape immigrants’ settlements and residency patterns” (1). This perspective was refreshing and different compared to others. Research should be done from this “close” a perspective in communities to really get a proper understanding of such things and possibly redirect some

Get Access