preview

The Censors And A Visit To Grandmother

Good Essays

Truth can be many things, both good and bad, but it can be harmful from trying to be helpful. Truth can be hidden to make others feel better, or not told at all so they are not burdened with it. In both “The Censors” by Luisa Valenzuela and “A Visit to Grandmother” by William Melvin Kelley, love is shown by hidden truth to protect their loved ones. In “The Censors,” Juan ventures to a censorship office to censor a letter to the woman he loves and is trying to protect, but is executed in the end. On the other hand, in “A Visit to Grandmother,” Charles holds the belief that his mother never loved him and when he finds out that she does, the root of the lie won’t let him believe the truth. In both stories, the belief that keeping the truth hidden …show more content…

However, setting can contribute to how important keeping the truth hidden is. In, “The Censors,” Juan describes the censorship office as having, “...a festive air on the outside that contrasted with its inner staidness,” (Valenzuela 412). Juan saying this can actually be related to the idea of keeping the truth hidden. Concealed truth can appear to be a good idea; keep your loved ones safe and not have to worry about their bruised feelings, just like how the outside of the censorship building had a festive air on the outside. However, keeping those tid-bits of truth hidden can harm much more than one would’ve first thought, similar to the dark secret inside of the censorship office. Juan wasn’t the first person to get the idea to censor their own letter, many had actually died because their secret was discovered and they suffered the cost. The truth being kept hidden was the only thing that was keeping Juan alive and working towards his goal of censoring his own letter to Mariana, which ended up killing him in the end. Likewise, when Charles and Chig went down for the high school reunion, they had, “...gone farther south, had just entered her house,” (Kelley 244) instead of going north. When Charles tells Chig that the reason he left his mother’s house was to go to school, he was telling the truth, but only a small part of it. Charles had left because he had felt unloved and rejected. Thinking he could do better elsewhere, he …show more content…

They can hide it, toy with it, and erase it simply because they think that it’s the right thing to do for the individual that they care about. Sometimes, however, hiding the truth isn’t a positive thing and can harm way more than it would have if the truth would have been spoken before. The conflict in both “The Censors” and “A Visit to Grandmother” helps contribute to hidden truth. By Juan taking this job, the risks of the truth come to mind, “Ulterior motives couldn’t be overlooked by the Censorship Division, but they needn’t be too strict with those who applied. They knew how hard it would be for the poor guys to find the letter they wanted and even if they did, what’s a letter or two when the new censor would snap up so many others?” (Valenzuela 411). Juan working at the censorship division not only ended up making him to lie to other people, but he started to deny his own self when he was moved up to the top division. He started to lie to himself when he thought he had found his true purpose. He is conflicted with staying true to his love, or forgetting it and going along with the job that could possibly harm Mariana. However, when the letter that Juan wrote Mariana lands in his hands, he wins his battle and censors it, with thoughts of finally keeping Mariana safe only to lose his life the very next day. On the contrary, in “A Visit to Grandmother,” Charles finally comes out and says the truth about something

Get Access