preview

The Brothers Karamazov By Fyodor Dostoevsky

Better Essays

It is a controversial, yet often agreed upon knowledge that some people are born more intelligent, charismatic, loving or even on the dark side. Furthermore, there is also the effect of one’s upbringing, surrounding environment and the influence of certain occurrences, particularly those that were neither anticipated nor facilitated by the individual. In this essay, I will explore the idea of how accountable and intensely criticized or praised one person should be for their choices that follow such constricted conditions. I will be studying characters from The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky, characters such as Alyosha who is said to be good by nature and Dimitry who is impulsive and emotional and naturally acts before he thinks. I argue that if against all odds of nature and uncontrollable circumstance one turns good, by definition of the novel, like Demitri or Ivan, possibly, that person should be the “hero.” In exploring this idea based on a perspective of information provided by the novel, I will mainly be focusing on the stories of those characters with the most detailed recount of not only their entire lives that exist in the novel, but also more importantly their upbringing and background. While other characters will be mentioned as support or relative influence, my central attention will be on the four Karamazov brothers; Alyosha, the good; S the evil; Ivan as the fight between good and evil and Dimitry the “evil” turned good. First we study the “hero,”

Get Access