preview

The Battle Of The Somme Was A Failure Essay

Decent Essays

“The Battle of the Somme was a complete disaster for the British” The Battle of the Somme took place over five months (between July and November of 1916) and the aim of it was to divert the attention of the Germans from Verdun. The first day was disastrous for the British consuming the biggest amount of British soldiers ever recorded in just 24 hours and the statement is probably based upon this. However the British did have a huge turn around. Source A disagrees with the statement given. It is a picture of a British tank taken in 1916 in Somme which shows men, who are smiling, gathered around a tank that has been ditched. It is likely that this is only prototype as we know tanks were only properly made in 1917. We also can infer that this was …show more content…

Though we do not know who produced the source, we can suggest that it was a commander or general trying to lift the hope of the soldiers by showing new advancements. This was taken in 1916, whilst the battle was ongoing which once again makes it seem like a reliable piece of evidence. The purpose of this source is not entirely clear but I think that it could have been photographed to show problems with the tank prototype in order to help the people making them improve the tanks so they would be more effective. This may also have been taken to lift the morale of not only the soldiers but also the rest of Britain. I think that this source is useful for us to make judgements and for us to use as evidence because the nature origin and purpose are all mainly reliable. For example in regard to the purpose, if we wanted to improve our prototypes, the commanders and generals would want to end accurate feedback so if this was the aim then it would have to be of factual nature. Then looking at the nature, which is a photograph as well as the time and lace where it was

Get Access