In August 1989, a decision shocked the baseball community as one of the game’s biggest icons, Pete Rose, agreed to permanent ineligibility from major league baseball activities for betting on his own team as both a player and manager. As a result, he was also banned for life from the Baseball Hall of Fame. A month ago, in September 2015, MLB’s all-time hits leader met with the commissioner of baseball, Rob Manfred, regarding the possibility of being granted induction into the Baseball Hall of Fame. This has once again sparked debate and divides baseball fans everywhere. There is no obvious correct answer and no sign of compromise. While some people firmly believe that Rose should be in the Hall of Fame for his record-smashing career, others believe he should be left out for the betting he did as a coach and a player.
Pete Rose’s play on the field is clear testament and obvious proof he is deserving of being inducted into the Hall of Fame. From the effort he put into every play earning him the nickname “Charlie Hustle”, to all the individual records and World Series rings he has earned, Pete Rose is a sure fire nominee to the Hall of Fame. He is remembered as one of the most dominating hitters of all time, “The man was an incredible offensive player and nothing can take that away from him. With numbers like his, there is no question that he is more than deserving of a place in the Hall” (Dunn). Pete Rose finished his career as the league 's leader in hits, at
The purpose to televising the episode, “ Does Barry Bonds Belong in the Hall of Fame,” is to express their opinion that he should be inducted, despite suspicion of steroid use and negative outlook from media, both Parker and Bayless believe Bonds is a “no doubt Hall of Famer.” The intended audience is directed towards baseball fans who are concerned whether Barry Bonds should get inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. The audience would also want the perspectives from professional sports commentators.
Frank Deford willingly accepts Pete Rose as a hall of fame worthy player, however, by using phrases like “the only person the ban benefits is Pete himself” and “the best thing that ever happened to Pete…” he argues that even though he lacks the golden title, Rose is more popular than ever. Deford’s report on Rose clearly demonstrates his admiration of the player and helps to shape the way the readers will view the person in question. Frank Deford establishes ethos as he gives many examples to show that he is not completely biased. Deford’s lack of bias is shown in phrases like “commissioners won’t change their minds on Pete Rose...”, where he mentions the commissioners as “commissioners” and doesn’t side with them as if they were fact. He also
Joe tells it as he sees it. He had the best performance by any world series player ever. However, after he was convicted of participating in the "Black Sox" scandal baseball officials revoked his controversial, but record breaking thirteenth hit. "And Shoeless Joe Jackson, indisputably one of the greatest ballplayers whoever lived set a World Series record by making twelve hits" (Gies and Shoemaker 59). "Perhaps it just isn’t easy for a good ballplayer to play badly" (Gies and Shoemaker 59). Before the first ball was ever thrown in the 1919 World Series, rumors were spreading that the game was fixed. "Cicotte
Pete Rose should be allowed eligibility to be inducted to the Hall of Fame. Pete Rose was one of the greatest players to ever step onto a baseball diamond. “During his career as a player. Rose won two N.L. batting titles, had ten 200-hit seasons, was named N.L. Rookie of the Year in 1963, and league MVP in 1973.” (Katz and Kuenster 43) With these achievements Rose also tallied a Major League Baseball record of 4,256 hits, six National League pennants, three World Series Championships and seventeen all-star game selections in his illustrious career.
Pete Rose is also known as charlie hustle, broke plenty of records during his career. He enjoyed playing for the reds and was in a good place in his career. He swapped between second base and outfield. Pete Rose also had a .305 batting average for a while and then he hit his 4000th on April 14th 1984. Pete Rose Cleary out batted Ty Cobb's former world record for the most all time hits and Rose even had 3,500 games, 14,000 at bats and, 10,000 outs.
Although Pete Rose was officially barred from the National Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, N.Y., because of a gambling scandal, he already has a major presence in the Cincinnati Reds Museum. Moreover, a statue of Rose, an All-Star at four different positions, is part of the "Great Eight" display honoring the "Big Red Machine" teams
Four years after setting the hits record, the MLB banned Pete Rose from baseball for life. The reason was one that was troubling to many, Rose had been betting on his team’s games (The Pete Rose Controversy). As any true fan knows, betting ruins the integrity of the game, which is held sacred in baseball. A ban from the baseball Hall of Fame came soon after Rose’s ban from baseball (The Pete Rose Controversy). The baseball Hall of Fame, a different organization that that of the MLB, created a rule that prevented any banned players from entering the Hall. This rule should be changed to allow Rose to enter the Hall of
In 1919, eight of the Chicago White Sox allegedly threw the World Series. Charles Comiskey was the ruthless owner of the White Sox and was the main motive of the sox to throw the series. Chick Gandil was the first player to get involved and then he spread it to the other players on the team. The act by these players would be called the Black Sox Scandal. The Scandal nearly ruined America’s pastime. The baseball commissioner, Judge Landis, banned all eight of the players for life. Based on how Joe Jackson played in the world series and how he was proven innocent in a court of law, he should be reinstated into baseball and be put in the hall of fame.
To some, including myself, baseball is the greatest sport that has ever been played. It is a game played by two opposing teams made of multiple players, but only nine players per team play at the same time. To be part of one of the thirty teams that get to play professional baseball, a player has to play the game extremely well (www.baseballhalloffame.com). When a player plays the game better than most have played he gets rewarded, usually with lots of money in a big contract. Then there are those rare players, the 244 elite players of the game that have already been inducted into the Hall of Fame. Being inducted in the Hall of Fame is the utmost of baseball fame. The players listed are remembered forever.
My controversial topic is on Pete Rose and how he should be inducted into Baseball’s Hall of Fame. Pete Rose was a player that I looked up to when I was a young boy playing baseball. I was a big fan of his collecting all of his baseball cards from rookie year up to the present time. Now, most of the baseball critics and others do not want Pete Rose inducted. They claim that his illegal betting on baseball games should keep him out of the Hall of Fame.
On July 23, 1962, in the charming village of Cooperstown, New York, four new members were inducted into baseball’s Hall of Fame. As they gathered around the wooden platform, the fans reminisced about America’s national pastime. Edd Roush and Bill McKechnie, sixty-eight and seventy-four years old respectively, were two of the inductees that day (Robinson 142). They were old-timers chosen by the veterans’ committee. Bob Feller and Jackie Robinson, both forty-two, were youngsters by comparison. According to the rules of the Hall of Fame, a player must be retired for five years before he can be considered for induction. Both Feller and Robinson were elected in the first year they were
“Does Pete Rose belong in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame?” This is a question that is debated among many pundits for a number of decades. Rose is undeniably one of the best hitters in the game of baseball. Twenty plus years ago, however, he was banned from the game due to the gambling allegations made against him. “Outside of baseball and my family, nothing has ever given me the pleasure, relaxation, or excitement that I got from gambling. Gambling provided an escape from the day-to-day pressures of life. And for me, gambling was just plain fun” (Rose and Hill 10). Regardless of Pete Rose’s history of betting on baseball, his outstanding performance and statistical achievements outweigh his off the field transgressions. Therefore he should be instated into the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame.
“Baseball is the only field of endeavor where a man can succeed three times out of ten, and be considered a good performer.” - Ted Williams. When referring to all time greats in the world of baseball you will hear about the likes of Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Ted Williams, Hank Aaron, Jackie Robinson, and Ernie Banks. None of these men have the most hits in baseball’s storied history. The man that does, however, is not in the Hall of Fame.
Body 1: Baseball trumps all other competitions because of the home for the all-time greats. Cooperstown, New York is home to the Baseball Hall of Fame, which is a heaven-like site where all of baseball’s best fanatics visit each and every year. They all come to learn about the players who have made this sport the best one out there. About 315,000 fans visit Baseball Heaven every year to learn about all 317 players who poured their blood, sweat, and tears into this fantastic game. That number of visitors is compared to the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame, in which only 37,000 people visited each year for the first 17 years to see 354 inductees’ plaques. Lastly, the induction ceremony of Cooperstown isn’t like any other. In 2007, 82,000
On the other hand, some believe that there comes a point in time when, after the players or coaches have suffered enough from their wrongdoings, these people should be rewarded and recognized for providing their sports with all of the glory they possibly could. For example, in the case of Pete Rose, some believe that he has served his time and should be voted into the MLB Hall of Fame due to the fact that he shattered records during his playing years. However, others do not think this way: they stay true to their belief that Rose should not be given such an honor due to the fact that he bet on the games.