This paper will review and critically evaluate a submission by The Australian Association of Social Workers (AASW). Being put forward to the Senate Education, Employment and workplace Relations Committee in 2012, in reference to “the adequacy of the allowance payment system for jobseekers and others, the appropriateness of the allowance payment system as a support into work and the impact of the changing nature of the labour market.” (Education, Employment and Workplace Relations Reference Committee, 2012).
To critique the AASW Submission it is essential to identify views on poverty historically and presently within Australia. Key problems and issues put forward the coherency of key arguments possible counter arguments to the ones presented
…show more content…
Relative poverty can only exist where there is inequality. nevertheless this does not mean that inequality and poverty are identical as not all forms of inequality will indicate relative poverty, only those in which individuals or groups fall well below the average. ASB(1996). Poverty alleviation is a central aim of economic and social policy, and yet there is no consensus about what poverty means or how it is best measured Thye measurement of poverty itself can have several risk factors with poverty measures such as the oldest and most widely used is that of income deprivation where the poverty line is the required disposable income needed to meet peoples basic needs. Saunders (2005) In Australia, we measure poverty can be defined by The proportion or number of those who earn below a set poverty line. This poverty line can be determined as relative meaning in relation to everyone else’s income. This increases as income increases. A fixed poverty line usually increase with inflation also known as the Henderson Poverty line, which was adopted concluding the report of the Commonwealth Commission of Inquiry into Poverty in 1974. More recently poverty has be calculated as being below 50 per cent of the median household income. This measurement tool is used by the Australian Council on Social services (ACOSS) which is a peak body for non-government welfare groups. Baum & …show more content…
With objectives surrounding social justice, changes to social policy and structures promoting equilaty, social inclusion and redressing social disadvantage. The AASW have addressed a number of issues of concern relating to the adequacy of the allowance payment system for job seekers and it’s appropriateness of the allowance payment system as a support into the work place, and the impact of the changing nature of the labour market. Amongst the reform concerns is the believe that the current newstart mutual obligations is highly categorised and discriminated between individuals seeking support. This is supported by ACCOSS (2012) finding that 60% of Newstart Allowance recipients have received the payment for over 12 months. One out of every three Newstart Allowance recipients is aged over 44. One out of every six recipients have a ‘partial work capacity’ (disability), meaning they can only work part time, but do not qualify for a Disability Support Pension. One out of every 15 recipients are a sole parent. Two out of every five recipients have less than Year 12 education. This demonstrates how diverse people on the newstart allowance are. Masking questions concerning how employable are many people on newstart especially those with
The Quebec legislature made substantial amendments to the Social Aid Act, R.S.Q., c. A-16, creating a new scheme in response to Quebec’s alarming and growing unemployment rate. This amendment is the one, which
Class divisions can result in tensions between people and different regions. Wage disputes between workers and employers in which workers try to improve their income levels are a common cause of dispute. These divisions can sometimes lead to social and economic instability. As shown earlier, inequality leads to poverty problems but the facts have not been explored. Australia has a very high level of relative poverty with 12.2% of Australians living below the poverty line, defined as receiving an income below 50% of the median income level. Poverty tends to trap families into a vicious cycle of low incomes and limited economic opportunities. High poverty levels also tend to be associated with increased levels of crime, suicide, disease and reduced life expectancy.
The social welfare in the UK is very different in practice for example benefits and services are delivered at minimum level as the coverage it widespread and can be too costly or even extensive. The social protection in which the welfare state provided is irregular and unpredictable and the services are rationed very tightly. As the services have been contracted out to self-reliant providers the control over the quality and reliability of social protection had been even more difficult to maintain. (Spicker2014)
The paper will look at ‘what is social exclusion’ and demonstrate how various groups and individuals are affected by it. It will further examine ‘what is social work’, its tasks and how these address social exclusion. This paper cannot examine all aspects of social exclusion, but will use examples of where social work is relevant in dealing with the issue. This paper looks at social work practice in particular in addressing issues arising from; poverty, unemployment, social policy and social work practice in relation to the social
Absolute poverty measurements are based upon a worldwide standard. They measure if a person is too able to earn enough money to satisfy the basic needs of individuals . This formation therefore looks at deprivation since it looks to see if you have enough to survive. Additionally this standard is a worldwide standard of what it expected to be needed by individuals to survive. Thus the absolute poverty measuring is a more fixed and world standard of measuring poverty. The Canadian version of this measurement is the MBM. It defines poverty as anyone who has a yearly income below the market basement, the amount that is defined as the minimum needed to have the access to the most basic necessities of life . The basement though will change as newer technological advances are deemed necessary for basic living . In 1988 this poverty line the market basement was $20,230 for a four person family. This is “roughly half of the LICO… poverty line incomes”
In the 21st century the unemployed or sole parent households become reliant on income support and non wage benefits L. Kirkwood et al: 2006). In 2002, 8.6 per cent of GDP was spent on social assistance benefits in cash to Australian residents L. Kirkwood et al: 2006). Total welfare expenditure in 2005-06 was $90.2 billion, of which $61.3 billion (68%) was cash benefits and $28.9 billion (32%) benefits-in-kind (welfare services). Spending on welfare services in 2005-06 was 3.0% of GDP or $1,404 per person (Welfare, 2011).
Before discussing the extent of poverty in Australia, it is first crucial to mention the difference between absolute poverty and relative poverty. Absolute Poverty is a situation where deprivation is extreme because people do not have access to the basic necessities such as food, clothing, and shelter. In contrast Relative Poverty is a situation in which the incidence of poverty is measured relative to things such as average weekly earnings or income per head. Therefore poverty, as talked about in Australia is the state where income is insufficient to meet the minimum needs of the household or individual.
There is significant need for a more simplified system for payment of benefits that also improves incentives to work. Customers that have previously been left to claim benefit with little or no intervention will have better access to face-to-face or telephone support. Jobcentre advisors will be given more freedom to assess customer’s needs and use their discretion in providing a personalised service.
Changes within the welfare system as a result of policy shifts and by new thinking, more generally in the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), have had many methods, but the one that seemed most important, was that welfare recipients were required to do much more to justify their income support payments than before. The foundation of this new idea is that income support programs should allow individuals to maximise their participation in work. Due to the general shift in welfare administration, the number of activity test requirements an individual in Australia must meet in order to receive unemployment benefits, has expanded significantly since the early 1990s. This complex, overly bureaucratic process means that disadvantaged individuals cannot access the income support payments they require.
The role of the Social worker is varied as it involves the facilitation of change and empowerment of the individual through social, cultural and environmental influences. Between 1910 and 1970, the role of the social worker was significant due to the impact of the Stolen Generation on Australian society. The Stolen Generation was a dark period in the Australian history where many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children were often taken without consent from their homes and families by the government, police and welfare authorities. The children were taken from their homes in order to try to ‘"civilize" them by assimilation into white society’ (McCarthy 2000). The impacts of this period often resulted in severe psychological consequences for the children, the loss of identity, social isolation, depression, alcohol abuse and an increased level of violence. The role of the Social Worker was significant during this period as they were often involved with removing children from their homes and were also required to participate in the reconciliation process to improve the relationships between Indigenous peoples and the wider Australian community. One of the lasting effects of this practice is the distrust of indigenous people towards the social welfare profession.
Social workers’ commitment to social justice means they want everyone to have a fair and equal opportunity to an assessment. In line with fairness, social workers should tell carers about their right to refuse an assessment as their permission, and not the person receiving care, is needed before the carer’s assessment can commence. In addition, social workers, bound by legislation regarding confidentiality and information sharing, must reserve the carer’s right to privacy whilst uphold their right to a fair hearing. This is achieved by only disclosing carer’s personal details to 3rd parties with consent, unless a safeguarding concern arises.
In the UK the definition used for absolute poverty is a household living on less than 60% of the median household income. While this is described as absolute poverty the way that it is measured against other incomes is, arguably, relative poverty. Whichever definition of poverty this figure should fall under, this definition will be used to determine whether poverty has been eliminated.
The Council on Social Work Education (CSWE) is a national association of educational programs and individuals that confirms and improves the quality of social work education to become a professional job. CSWE puts in a countless amount of effort to strive for this mission by setting up a bachelor's and master’s degree programs in social work. On the other hand, the National Association of Social Workers (NASW) is the largest membership organization of professional social workers in the world, with approximately 132,000 members. To be more specific, NASW has a determination to intensify the maturity and developmental process of its members. The main goal is to retain professional standards and to create fair social policies. NASW progresses
In economically developed nations such as New Zealand, poverty is conceptualised as “relative” rather than "absolute". The Solutions to Child Poverty report describes child poverty as: “those who experience deprivation of the material resources and income that is required for them to develop and thrive, leaving such children unable to enjoy their rights, achieve their full potential and participate as equal members of New Zealand society.” (Children’s Commissioner Report [CCR], 2012, p. 2.).
In 2010, about 46.2 million people were considered poor. The nation’s poverty rate rose to 15.1 percent, whereas in 2009, 14.3 percent of people in America were living in poverty (Censky, 2011). That is an increase of 2.6 million people in 2010. In the United States, the federal poverty line – an absolute measure of annual income – is frequently used to determine who is categorized as poor (Ferris & Stein, 2008, 2010). Currently the government defines the poverty line as an income of $11,139 for an individual and $22,314 for a family of four (Censky, 2011). In sociology, poverty can be defined using two terms – relative deprivation and absolute deprivation. Relative deprivation is a comparison between people and social class. With