preview

The Alcoholic Republic : An American Tradition

Decent Essays

In his book, The Alcoholic Republic: An American Tradition, William J. Rorabaugh makes the argument that early American society was a place where alcohol flowed freely through every level of society. Americans in the late eighteenth century and into the nineteenth century partook in so widely it was one of the defining characteristics of the culture of the early United States. Using data collected from censuses, surveys, and reports from those who traveled across the country in its early years, Rorabaugh concludes that the drinking in the United States found no barriers with age, sex, race, class, or location. But his assumptions and conclusion are not proved strongly enough by hard evidence and data to be considered a reliable narrative of the early America. The first problem that his conclusions face is the scarce amount of statistical data from the colonial era onwards. The few surveys he is able to find are mostly either production records or sales records that do not provide an accurate picture of how, when, where, and by whom the alcohol was consumed. Although these surveys give a good window into the amount of alcohol in early America by looking at how much was produced and how much of it was sold, it cannot truly be used to document American drinking habits. In the same way a window into a home may be used to get a solid understanding of the kitchen but may not show the living room, basement, or bedrooms, this data is insufficient to make wide reaching claims

Get Access