preview

The 1950's Scene Analysis

Decent Essays

Both films throughout contain ample voice-over from the father character about his experience with the engagement and wedding preparation, however in these parallel sequences the voice-overs are not used to the same extent nor to the same end. Neither scene contains any sound besides dialogue and voice-over, and the 1950 scene only uses one instance of voice over throughout. The aforementioned line about lying is the only exclusive insight into Stanley’s experience, and although this could imply that the behavior he shows following this is dishonest it seems more so to be a nod to the stakes of a successful first impression. Ellie’s inner-workings shine through just as much in this sequence with her clear performance indications of what she …show more content…

Other moments in the 1991 version use closer framing than the 1950 version in a way that hones in on what specifically is bothering George in moments with multiple characters interacting. Keeping the audience in the loop with him as the pace and cutting move quickly creates a feeling of being dragged into this along with him. The cultural context in 1950 has an audience that is not only accustomed to a straight-forward method of filming compared to more modern traditions of “intensified continuity” (Bordwell 121), but is also more likely to see reason in Stanley’s point of view without needing to be presented it from as many methods as in 1991. A father grappling with no longer having the final word in his (albeit young) daughter’s decision making makes sense within an older social context, and Stanley comes off as lenient and loving as he works past his apprehensions to support her. Taking this storyline entirely at face value and presenting it with the same style would not have the same effect for the 1991 adaptation, and so not only does the film add narrative changes to what is suspicious about the engagement, the formal elements consistently stay aligned with George in a manner that keeps the audience conscious of what is drawing his responses. Insight into what bothers him and what appeases him about the whole process, and formal depiction of the extent of his genuine concern, make his story read heartwarming as well. The remake can retain the heart of the original story largely through the effect of contemporary filming practices that guide attention, and in doing so in this film give the audience the right understanding of the roundabout paths these fathers take to lovingly support their

Get Access