preview

Terminally Ill Patients: A Case Study

Decent Essays

Is withdrawing life support in order to end the life of the patient considered an act of murder or an act of kindness? If the patient is on life support to recover from an injury or an illness, it probably is murder. If the patient is terminally ill and asks to be released, it could be an act of kindness, but by section 166.047 of Texas’s Advance Directives Act it is not murder. It becomes trickier when the patient is unable to consent because of severe impairment of sanity or cognitive ability. Thus, in the case of a comatose, terminally ill patient is dependent on life support, the patient’s family should be allowed to have it withdrawn to let the patient die.
The Case of Nancy Cruzan
In 1990, Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of …show more content…

The patient is most affected; after all, they are the one who lives or dies. If the patient is disconnected the patient will die and would be free from any pain they may have dealt with. If they are kept connected they may have to continue to endure the pain for the rest of their lives. The patient’s family and friends would be impacted next as they would have the second-hand experience to the patient’s ups, downs, death, and direct experience to the aftermath. If the family made the decision, they would have to deal with the choice they made whether or not they thought it was ultimately the best choice. The medical staff is on a lower tier because they were responsible for the patient’s health and well-being as long as the patient is under their care and would likely be the one to pull the …show more content…

The people involved should know all of the options before they make a decision. The patient’s condition should be taken into account. Each patient has a different disease or illness, severity, symptoms, and medical conditions. For example, section 166.049 of Texas’s Advance Directives Act doesn’t allow life support to be removed or refused if the patient is pregnant. In that case, both the baby and the mother would die if the mother was taken off of life support, but even then the ethics of that situation can differ from person to person and the laws could differ depending on the state’s abortion laws. Also, while money should not be the deciding factor, it should be taken into account. Back when Jahi McMath was on life support in 2013, the cost of the treatment in the intensive care unit was $2,000 to $4,000 a day at the very

Get Access