preview

Teenage Rebellion Research Paper

Decent Essays

The Similarities and Differences of the Causes of the
Rebellion in Upper and Lower Canada

The causes of the Rebellions of 1837 in Upper and Lower Canada have similarities and differences. For example, both Upper and Lower Canada had problems with their government, not having a representative or responsible one. They also both had a group, the Family Compact in Upper Canada and the Chateau Clique in Lower Canada, that had a lot of money and power. Another similarity is that they both had a document trying for change that got shut down by the government, Gourlay’s petition in Upper Canada, and the 92 Resolutions in Lower Canada. The proposed union of 1822 also contributed to the Rebellions of 1837 in both Upper and Lower Canada, as both they disapproved of union of the two colonies. The proposed union of 1822 could also be considered a difference in the causes of the rebellions, since the union would make the French in Lower Canada, a …show more content…

Firstly, the government in both Upper and Lower Canada both were neither representative nor responsible, it was an oligarchy. Even though ‘anyone’ (landowning men) could have been elected as part of the Legislative Assembly, the Legislative Assembly only could suggested ideas. Any suggestions could be vetoed by the councils or the governor, who were all appointed by Britain, making the assembly ultimately have no power in the government. This was a huge issue because the councils were mostly made up of the Family Compact (in Upper Canada) and the Chateau Clique (in Lower Canada). Which leads to the second similarity of the causes, the power structures, the Family Compact and the Chateau Clique. Both of these upper class groups wanted different things than the lower classes. An example is that the Family Compact wanted to build canals instead of roads and the Chateau Clique wanted the

Get Access