preview

Summary Of Secret Life Of The Manic Depressive By Stephen Fry

Good Essays

In the documentary The Secret Life of the Manic Depressive, British comedian Stephen Fry shares some of his experiences living with bipolar disorder–a diagnosis he received at the age of 37. His diagnosis came after what he refers to as a definite suicide attempt (rather than a cry for help), even though he did not suffer any physical harm. What I find interesting about his attempt is that as he sat in his car with his hand on the ignition for at least two hours in a sealed garage, he imagined both of his parents staring at him the entire time. It was this image of his parents that Stephen said prevented him from going through with turning the key. A common belief throughout both parts of the documentary that I find unusual (to …show more content…

Liz Miller, for example, prefers a holistic approach to a pharmacological approach. She refuses to take anti-psychotics and instead takes 3 grams of cod liver oil daily. I rejoiced when I heard she hadn’t had an episode (despite her psychiatrist’s assurance of an inevitable one) for the past 15 years. Richard Dreyfuss, on the other hand, shared that he is gradually weaning himself off of Lithium after having taken the drug since the late seventies. Results from treatments of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) were shared by Andy Behrman. For him, medicine did not work; ECT, however, did. I cringe at the thought of ECT, but have to admit to being impressed with the results Andy got from his treatments (despite his short-term memory loss). Stephen, although having never taken a psychotropic, admits toward the end of the documentary that medication may be something he would consider if indeed his condition is deteriorating. Preference (which could lead to noncompliance) certainly needs to be taken into consideration both in research of and treatment with mental health pharmacology. Personally, I tend to lean toward a more holistic approach to mental health relief, with the exception of schizophrenia and other physiologically-based …show more content…

In England, keeping up appearances is paramount (for some) to maintaining social acceptance, and social obligations are held in high esteem. In people with bipolar disorder, these cultural norms seem to be easily converted to neuroses, overt concerns with the opinions of others, and lessened self-esteem as a result of those opinions. In the documentary, for example, Stephen’s sister described his reaction to the less-than-optimal reviews of one of his performances as him having “a hissy fit.” It was also his imagery of his parents looking on while contemplating suicide that prevented him from completing the attempt. 27-year-old Zoe Schwartz was described as being “desperate to be a success,” and a close friend said (regarding her suicide) that “it was her pride [that] killed her.” Even Cordelia Feldman, when asked pointedly, “I mean what’s it say about you if you can’t write?” by her cognitive behavioral therapist Jan Scott of the Institute of Psychiatry in London, was left speechless and emotional in response. When she was able to talk, she replied with what I know to be typically English: “I hate weakness in myself.” Teaching vulnerability, I believe, would therefore be a beneficial addition to CBT in treatment for clients of similar cultural

Get Access