preview

Summary: Judge Tuttle

Decent Essays

During this announcement was when I first got a sense of Judge Tuttle’s personality and her nature in the courtroom. While the Honorable Judge Tuttle did have everything under control and organized in her courtroom, she was a very easy-going counselor. She let us know that the jurors were just finishing up their donuts that the court had provided them and ask us if that was okay with us despite the case already being delayed. She had a very nonchalant approach to her. Looking back in comparison to the interview I conducted with Judge Tuttle it makes sense. In her interview I came to find out she had never took a law class during her undergrad, but actually majored in art history, which probable explains why she had such an abstract approach …show more content…

Manual was very calm and comfortable in the courthouse. Almost as if he was a veteran, and seeing how he is the Deputy District Attorney of Weld county I’m sure he has some experience under his belt. Within the first five minutes after the judge entered the room he got straight down to business. Asking for a proposed instruction for evidence being presented the jury be reworded and completely restructured. It was a very meticulous process that the court spent well over five minutes combing over while we waited on the jury. Throughout the day Mr.Pellicer was very blunt and confident, almost to a fault. Any objections or suggestions Mr.Pellicer made in court, Ms.Pearlman (the defending attorney) seemed to say "me too" after. It seemed almost as if she was playing catch up in with the prosecutor. In hindsight, the first five minutes of the case were a great foreshadowing for the events to come. He seemed very passionate about the case and condemning Mr.Olmeda. During direct examination Mr.Pellicer was very concise and direct with his questions, building a great base for his argument. The dichotomous questioning allowed for a great establishment of time, facts, opinions, and evidence. There were rarely any awkward pauses, or moments of shuffling through paperwork during questioning. In fact, Mr.Pellicer made a great use of the pauses during his questioning …show more content…

It was very intriguing to see the finally results of voir dire, peremptory challenges, and the numerous other aspects that go into jury selection. The jury consisted of seven women, five males, and was predominantly Caucasian past their forties. Which for a fifty-eight-year-old Latino male, this was far from a representation of Jerry Olmeda’s peers. Aside from the gender, age and race gap the jury didn’t seem to emotionally invested or interested in the case until accounts of assault came up. Up until the daughter’s testimony, and showing of Andrea’s account of the sexual assaults she encountered, most of the jury just stared blankly at the court proceedings. But as soon as the recording started, you could see the jurors started to take notes and become more

Get Access