preview

Study Design: A Randomized Cross-Over Trial

Better Essays

Student comments in this section— 5a. The study design was experimental and further classified as a randomized cross-over trial. The best study design was selected in order to compare subjects with themselves using the different music interventions. 5b. The design study adequately examines all objectives, questions, hypothesis and purpose of the study. The study tries to control erroneous variables by randomizing the subjects into groups A and B by a randomized computer generator. This was done because subjects were their own controls due to difficult randomization. The study took place over 3 days and each day 3 hours of observations were performed. An unbiased ABS rater was used and rating compared to primary researcher prior to study. The subjects were treated during their daily routines. 5c. The study included treatment/intervention called preferred music listening and classical relaxation music. The preferred music listening and classical relaxation music were described adequately and observations were conducted 1 hour prior to music medicine preferred/classical music, 1 hour after music intervention, and after 1 hour of silence after intervention. 5d. The study tries to control extraneous variables by randomizing the subjects into groups A and B by a randomized computer generator. This was done because subjects were their own …show more content…

Construct validity is somewhat weak based on patients that preferred rap and heavy metal music, they showed signs of increased agitation during preferred music intervention. Statistical conclusion validity is strong because it too into account the male to female ratios, types of injuries, and other factors during the results section. External validity is weak due to the study was only conducted in one site and may have reduced generalizability. Internal Validity is strong because subjects were randomized, no subjects withdrew from the study, and no unrelated events occurred during the study that would affect

Get Access