Numerous scholarly literature in nursing has found that men who chose to pursue a career in nursing were faced with various challenges and barriers. For many years, male nurses has struggled with the stereotypes placed on them due to the dominance of women in the nursing profession. As a consequence of this, male nurses were not well accepted by society, despite their growing number and the support from groups for male nurse equality. The decades of generalizing nurses as merely females has caused male nurses to face discrimination from educators, patients, and other nurses. The notion of caring as being a uniquely feminine trait has ultimately contributed to the marginalization of men within the nursing sector. Men in nursing are subjected to unjust discrimination due to their minority status in the nursing profession.
MEN AS A MINORITY IN THE NURSING PROFESSION
Men in nursing represent a small but growing percentage of the nursing population. According to a survey conducted by the U.S. Census Bureau (2011), there were 3.5
…show more content…
In 2005, the American Assembly for Men in Nursing, several other nursing groups, and Bernard Hodes Group conducted an online survey on the issues related to male nurses and male nursing students. Of the 498 men who responded, 93% were registered nurses and 7% were students. The findings showed that 73% of the men in nursing found that negative stereotypes still thrive in the nursing industry. Eighty-two percent of the respondents noted that nursing is identified as a woman-dominated profession which is not suited for men because they are not caring, and that men in nursing are gay. Fifty-six percent of those surveyed experienced difficulties in their nursing education and were often perceived as muscle by women colleagues. Additionally, 42% reported that lack of male models and mentors have led to the limited number of men in the nursing
According to the U.S. Census Bureau men made up 7.6% of nurses in the year 2000 (Landivar, 2013). Even though this does seem like a small number, the amount of males in this profession has risen exponentially from 1970 and continues to rise. In the year 2011, around 330,000 males were nurses (Landivar, 2013). This is why I decided to choose the film Meet the Parents (produced in
Meadus and J. Creina Twomey. They both have a PhDs, they are also Both RNs. Robert J. Meadus is an associate professor while J. Creina Twomney is an assistant professor. They are both credible sources because they are both Register Nurses and also they both have a PhD. They both work for the School of Nursing, Memorial University, St. John’s, Newfoundland, Canada. They are biased because they are both males who are also nurses. They feel that more males should be accepted into nursing universities. The article informs the reader that in many countries such as the Unites states, Canada, Ireland the percentage of male nurses is relatively small compare to those of female nurses. The article also discusses the research done on males to see their experience as students in a nursing school. The main point of the article is that nursing schools should re-evaluate how they teach and promote the nursing career. They have to do so in a way to provide gender neutrality for both male and female students. “Nursing is predominantly a female-concentrated occupation. Mackintosh (1997) states that despite men being “pioneers” within the profession, they are considered an “anomaly” for choosing a career outside the boundaries for men in non-traditional occupations.” ( Meadus &
Nursing was a challenge to the individual and I had to experience an identity I had never previously thought about which was being a male within a predominantly female career field. As Yang et al. (2004) showed males in their study work towards promotion and strive on a long term goal of personal growth. In previous fields I had always fought for advancement and now I still do and have been equally been treated among my peers and have seen that advancement truly can only come from pursuing an advanced degree.
One full of acceptance and hope. The modern approach combined nursing education with the American culture and would be reflected on the unisex uniform, allowing both men and women of any race into the workplace. The changes in society, post World Wars, lead to “needs for more liberated generation of women, nursing had to escape the time wrap of feminized culture within a paternalistic structure” (Bates 125). For the first time ever, any person was accepted and respected in the workforce. Simultaneously “a grave concern over the public image of nursing and the role of uniform played in that image spawned a large body of literature, written by nurses, examining and critiquing the derogatory portrayal of the nurse in print, television, and film” (Bates 143).
Thus explaining that regardless of one’s skill set they base the choice of career or lack of career on their cultural beliefs and when a male or female steps outside of the boundary that society has placed they are chastised for their decision. For example, in 2013 94% of nurses were females and only 6% were males, Wilson (2013) indicated the primary reason for this being that society views nursing as a care taking role with the best nurses having a maternal instinct (p. 1). Therefore, placing a more family orientated role on the nursing field. Although, Wilson (2013) also established that regardless of nursing being a more female orientated career, males still made approximately $1,100 more than their female counterparts. Leading to the realization that society even in a female oriented career field still places more value on men than women when it comes to a career driven
This essay focuses on the impact of historical development of nursing on contemporary representations of the nursing profession. It examines the professional identity of nursing and further discusses the contribution of modern nursing, social, cultural and political factors that influences the professional identity of a nurse. The essay also looks into the professional regulations and the role of the nurse’s and midwifery Council (NMC) in the protection of the public. Finally, this essay will discuss nursing education, the media, stereotype, and their impacts on nurses as well as demonstrate my understanding as a student nurse to challenge the professional identity of nurses.
Even after decades, not much has changed regarding men in this specific career path. When we see movies like “meet the parents” in which the father in law constantly makes fun of Ben Stiller for being a male nurse when he clearly loves his job doesn’t seem to be fair. It is interesting to note that women today have taken positions in programs such as engineering, medicine, and law. However, they are not talked about as much as men in nursing field. Although females continue to exceed men as nurses significantly, the stats of male nurses have increased. The document “Men in nursing occupations” by liana Christian
New advertisements for the nursing field include posters designed for this campaign aimed to boost the attractiveness of the image of men in nursing by illustrating concepts of brotherhood, belonging, men helping men, and leading the way. One of the recent posters out there shows a student nurse "reverse mentoring" another nurse with technology proving that this is an educational line of work. AAMN, American Assembly for Men in Nursing, hopes that these contemporary images of professional, compassionate, and competent nurses will chip away at stereotypes about men in nursing (Stokowski
Stereotypes affect all of us, more so when we are not aware of them. Recognizing stereotypes helps us to move past them. Choose one stereotype about nursing. In at least three paragraphs, describe the stereotype, show an example of the stereotype from literature, television, a movie, etc., and then describe how the stereotype could positively and negatively affect the image of nursing. Cite your sources in APA format. Save your work as a Word document and submit as an attachment in Blackboard.
The nursing profession is one of those that is held in very high esteem. Nurses have and continue to be thought of as most trustworthy and have been in some polls ranked even higher than clergy. The role of the nurse is one that comes with much responsibility and is a very demanding profession. which requires a lot of grit and commitment. With the advancements in modern technology and medicine and more and more the general population realizing the need for positive changes in their lifestyle which include healthy eating, regular exercise and not participating in risky behaviors. Our population life expectancy has increased in recent decades this together with our exploding population has created an ever growing demand for nursing and medical
Over the decades, the field of nursing has been facing difficulty with receiving acceptance as a respectable occupation. This is because there were often certain prejudices associated with the profession (which made it hard to attract good candidates). However, in the last several years, nurses have become an integral part of any health care team. To fully understand how this took place requires examining the historical trends. This will be accomplished by focusing on: self-regulatory issues and the way social perceptions impacted career decisions. Once this takes place, is when these elements will show the challenges effecting the development and practices of the discipline. (Kitson, 1996, pp. 1647 1651)
Negative and unflattering stereotypes about nurses such as the sexy nurse, the physician’s handmaiden, glamorous hair, short skirt, and heavy makeup only damage the profession and drive candidates male or female away from the profession. Who wants to be part of a profession,
The Motion picture film, “Sentimental Women Need Not Apply”, highlighted that the first group of nursing students were all white women (1988). Black women were unwelcomed in some nursing schools hence nursing schools were establish for colored people only (Gary & Hott, 1988). One nurse shared that the lack of black doctors rendered black nurses as the sole healthcare providers in some communities. After years of speaking out against segregation, any capable human, regardless of race or gender can now become a nurse. In the 21st century both men and women of all cultures are welcome to becoming a nurse. Though nursing remains a female dominated profession, the gap between male and female nurses has narrowed. In 1970, three percent of nurses were males compared to ten percent in 2013 (Tanner,
According to the U.S. Cenus Bureau, male nurses make up 9% of all registered nurses in the country in 2011. The number of male nurses in 1970 was about 3%, so you can see the numbers gradually rising (Landivar). If over 3.2 million of the
Male nurses are not typically encouraged by the society we live in today. Men are not in favor of being called nurses and maybe would have a bit more encouragement if the caregiver word would simply be changed from ‘nurse’ to ‘medic’ (Gorgos). Just the change in title can make a positive difference to both men and women in the nursing field. Men and women enter the nursing career with the same goals and interests; but are still yet separated by the name ‘nurse’ and ‘male nurse’ (Kouta). Eddie Hebert a 35-year nursing veteran claims that the caregiver one usually pictures a white woman. This image is being projected into the American public. He believes that, “Caregiving is not feminine; it's universal.” The lack of men in nursing though is, “a result of cultural stereotypes and image” (Gorgos). On the