preview

Stanley Fish's Stepping On Jesus

Decent Essays

Stanley Fish’s article Stepping On Jesus, talks about the idea of a higher power and how some will defy higher authorities in order to respect their values. While not everyone believes in a higher power, many will still show signs of respect and will demonstrate the power of iconic symbols in their lives. Throughout his article, Fish states many different points and beliefs on what is right and what may be controversial topics to others. Fish’s article in the New York Times, he aims to show both sides of the controversial assignments given to students, these assignments aim for the beliefs and strong views that students hold. They start discussions and many students even refuse to complete them due to their insensitivity to their beliefs. …show more content…

Many students denied doing this due to the lack of disrespect on Jesus’s name. Although many of the students were not particularly religious or believe in Christianity they still showed a sign of respect by refusing to step on the paper. This proves the power that iconic symbols hold, although some may not necessarily believe in them they still hold the respect and care as if they did believe. Fish was convincing when stating that students respect the iconic symbols. He used several examples of students who defied their authorities in order to stick up for what they believe in. Fish starts with the controversy at Florida Atlantic University, the Professor, Deandre Poole tells his students to write the name Jesus on a piece of paper and then to proceed by stepping on it. This assignment made several students angry, they refused to proceed with the assignment and believed that their beliefs were being attacked. Poole reassures that he did not want to attack anyone in particular, he was simply trying to reaffirm the students’ faith and showing them how much iconic symbols actually affect them but they aren’t completely …show more content…

Although this is simply an assignment to imagine and persuade someone to believe what you are telling them, many parents along with the superintendent of schools believed it to be very disturbing. This required role playing, just like the other few cases, required students to take a side they did not believe in, and try to convince others that they did believe in it. A third of the students at the high school refused to participate, demonstrating the power of an iconic symbol and how it changes their perspective on things. Students did not want to be associated with the Nazi, as a fear to be believed they really were one. The assignment made a few people uneasy and as a result led to students to refuse to

Get Access