preview

Social Criticism In Shooting An Elephant By George Orwell

Decent Essays

George Orwell's essay "Shooting an Elephant" portrays demanding situations as the leading cause of people desperately attempting, disregarding what is right or wrong, to save their egos from social criticism. More specifically, by saying that he was "an absurd puppet pushed to and fro by the will of those yellow faces behind," Orwell argues that his actions felt predetermined by the will of the Burmese and that, just as he had done, humanity's fear of defying expected social roles causes people to contradict socially conscious behavior, leading to a variety of negative consequences, many of them being inhumane. Although there are minor cases in which people exert their free will and act of their own accord regardless of pressure they are under, …show more content…

With the fear of being different from the group, subjects within Asch's experiment would lie about which lines they believe are the same height. They self-doubt themselves and find that no other option is valid. 75% of participants, when observing the group's answers, heeded to their consensus and gave the wrong answer. Asch's experiment revealed people's motivation in group circumstances to be driven by a need for conformity and a fear of going against popular opinion. Just as it was within Milgram's experiment, there were outliers who refused to comply, but in Asch's experiment the people who defied the group intimidation did so when there were one or two other contestants who did not conform, showing that people are less likely to go against their beliefs if they see other people expressing themselves. This is to say that group collectivism is exemplified when there is only one person against a large population and that a group holds enough power to manipulate a single individual. This is crucial in examining that, if a person holds enough fear of being different, they can go to any lengths, in spite of what is righteous, to fit in and this is problematic if there were anyone to take advantage of this fear, just as it has been done in cases such as

Get Access