preview

Similarities Between Edgar Allan Poe And The Fall Of House Of Usher

Decent Essays

When you think mysterious gothic stories authors’ names like Edgar Allan Poe and Nathaniel Hawthrone may come to your mind. Poe’s short story “The Fall of House of Usher,” is undoubtingly a great story, with his clever use of literature to the theme of consuming death. However, when placed on the side of Hawthrone’s short story, “The Minister’s Black Veil,” it meets its match. Hawthrone explores the theme of isolation through the mood and descriptive detail, making it the ideal story. Both stories share many similarities and differences between their style of writing, the symbols, the themes, the characters, and the moods.
“The Fall of the House of Usher,” starts off with the narrator receiving a letter from an old childhood friend, symbolizing Roderick’s despair as he asks the narrator for help to cope with the illness that his sister, Madeline, is infected by. Another symbol he uses in his short story is the mansion; it is one of the reasons the Roderick gets sucked into his sadness. “I looked onto the scene before me… an utter depression of the soul…,” (Poe 294) describes the feeling the house conveys to the readers. In Hawthrone’s story, “The Minister’s Black Veil,” the reverend walks in the church with a black veil that covers his face, it is portrayed as a way to isolate and punish himself for a sin he has committed, which contrasts to the letter in Poe’s story when he is more open to getting help. The church is another symbol Hawthrone explores, he uses it as a place that he is isolating himself within which is similar to Poe’s symbol of the mansion where Roderick is stuck within the walls in his own home. Edgar Allan Poe is most known for the way he structures his stories. The way that he organizes his story chronologically plays out the theme of consuming death most effectively by increasing the sadness Roderick feels throughout the story. In comparison, Hawthrone uses the same structure to go through each main point of how they treat him with the veil on, leading up to the death of the reverend when he still refuses to take off the veil. When each story is written, the point of view it is told by demonstrates the work and thought each author puts in their story. In “The Fall of the House of Usher,”

Get Access