preview

Shooting An Elephant

Decent Essays

Often the most provocative discoveries are those made from situations that challenge us, that is, the situations we often do not expect to encounter or the situations that differ from our expectations. Ernesto ‘Che’ Guevara’s memoir The Motorcycle Diaries outlines his travels through Latin America with his friend Alberto Granado. Through his own challenging experiences, Guevara details the way how some important and meaningful revelations cannot be made without them. The essay ‘Shooting an Elephant’ by George Orwell details the incident of an Imperial officer having to shoot an elephant, catalysing and clarifying important realisations about imperialism. Both realise the profound impact of challenging experiences on our process of discovery …show more content…

The essay is narrated by a colonial policeman, presumably Orwell himself, in British Burma who mentions that killing the elephant “gave me a better glimpse than I had had before of the real nature of imperialism,” already foreshadowing the impact of the incident. Shooting the elephant proves to be a difficult task to recover from as the graphic imagery of the elephant’s blood welling out like “red velvet” while juxtaposed with its “great agony” suggests the significant impact of its pain on the shooter. The elephant is an innocent figure, shown by the simile comparing it to a cow, in this essay who pays the price for the white man’s superiority complex due to imperialism. Orwell recognises in the moment that he is “an absurd puppet pushed to and fro by the will of those yellow faces behind” and so fulfils the duty of a “sahib,” suggesting how the difficult experience of shooting an innocent looking animal has led him to further understand the effects of imperialism on the oppressors. The narrative like structure of the essay allows Orwell to formulate his thesis through an incident he learned from. He comes to the conclusion that “every white man’s life in the East was on long struggle not to be laughed at”, exemplifying how his motives for shooting the elephant were ultimately to “avoid looking a …show more content…

Guevara’s memoir exemplifies this notion for his discoveries evoke several emotions within him that transform him as he goes through Latin America. The memoirs are structured sequentially, allowing the audience to witness Guevara’s progression as a person. When Ernesto examines a woman with asthma in Valparaiso, his language becomes increasingly emotive, the woman described as “the poor thing was in a pitiful state” before he goes on to generalise the poor who are especially ill, feeling himself long “for change: a change to prevent the injustice of a system.” Here, Guevara witnesses the harsh life the poor endure; a provocative discovery that pushes him towards revolutionary thought, suggesting that often harsh discoveries are the most provocative. The exposure to communism has another profound impact upon Ernesto as his diary entries become more political, particularly in ‘Chuquicamata’, where he describes the mine to be like “a modern drama” whose beauty is “imposing” and “glacial.” The simile suggests that there is more to this mine than what meets the eye as he reveals this when his language shifts from lightly poetic to heavily emotive when he calls the poor “unsung heroes of this battle who die miserably…when all they want is to earn their daily bread.” Guevara mentions the political context surrounding the

Get Access