preview

Scalpel And The Silver Bear Analysis

Better Essays

Many people wonder what people think about them. They may think they have to fit in with the crowd. But to have everyone the same would be a boring world. Everybody has something different to contribute because we are all different. Different customs, cultures, and traditions. On a medical team, everyone performs different roles. Some may be better at other things than others, or think differently because of their culture and where they came from. The book of The Scalpel and the Silver Bear by Lori Alvord includes all of the three narratives of assimilation, antagonism, and bridging. But the main ones may be assimilation and bridging. During her life she goes through all of these in order to become a Navajo surgeon. The Navajo tribe have their …show more content…

In Marcia’s story, she goes through assimilation. She tries hard to immerse herself into the white American culture, and ignores her Hispanic roots. It starts when she is in school, she lies about where she lives because she is ashamed of her real house. She even changes her name to Marsha to feel accepted by her white classmates. They do accept her somewhat, but her fellow Hispanic classmates call her “whitewashed”. “But reading and learning English do not mean that I fit in. I refuse to speak Spanish anymore, deciding to do whatever it takes to feel accepted” (Casas 39). Marcia denies that she speaks Spanish to a man that asked her if she spoke it. And during school ceremonies she feels embarrassed for her father to come up stage due to his appearance. But she eventually accepts her culture, she declines a $75,000 scholarship to say in what she believes …show more content…

And so that she could feel good about herself, knowing that she is giving back to her people by something she loves to do along with her tradition. I do agree with Huntington about we have to have enemies in order to belong somewhere. Not everybody in the world will like you, there will always be negative people in life. But you cannot let them what you can and cannot do, like how Marcia’s counselor said she should just focus on graduating high school when Marcia mentioned she wanted to go to college. There does not have to be adoption in all aspects of mainstream culture to succeed. People should be proud of who they are and where they come from, instead of worrying what other people think. Everyone is unique, and that is what makes the medical field strong. Everybody has different ideas, experiences, and methods of doing things. It would not be beneficial to have everyone in the same culture. It takes several ingredients to make a good tasting sandwich, or only a one or two to make a bland tasting

Get Access