preview

Salinger's Short Story Analysis

Decent Essays

Salinger’s dialogue that reveals his character 's’ innermost workings, and he does so despite the swarm of academics that rally against him. High school writing classes across the country are fighting the perceived menace of the word “said.” They print lists of alternate verbs, hang posters that say “Said is Dead,” and push students to page through thesauruses, creating an unbearable tide of big-word writers afraid to use a four-letter word. In this rising tide Salinger’s writing is all the more refreshing, for he is the patron saint of “Said.” People don’t “sputter” in Salinger’s short stories. They don’t pled or moan or ramble. They don’t sob sentences, laugh soliloquies, or whisper monologues. They don’t need to. They simply “say.” A …show more content…

There’s an unwritten law that people in a certain social or financial bracket can name-drop as much as they like just as long as they say something terribly disparaging about the person as soon as they’ve dropped his name -- that he’s a bastard or a nymphomaniac or takes dope all the time or something horrible. She broke off again’” (25).

Franny’s response is a series of fragments and broken-off sentences that span two pages. Two concepts are communicated simultaneously. First, the content of Franny’s speech. Second, the back-last or second-guessing that goes on within Franny’s head. The first is the more well-known and more controversial of the two. Franny has been critiqued for so-called shallow concerns. John Updike famously referred to Franny as, “a pretty college girl passing though a plausible moment of disgust” in his New York Times review of Franny and Zooey. He calls Franny “pretty” to demean her intelligence. He calls her “girl” to demean her perspective. His use of “plausible” indicates that he finds her character understandable. John Updike may be a wonderful author and an eloquent reviewer, but he will never understand Franny. I understood her when I read “Franny” for the first time. There is no trick to it, it is simply that she was speaking for me. Updike, well, perhaps Lane was speaking for him. Throughout lunch Lane tries to teach, tame, and turn Franny into what he believes she

Get Access