preview

Reasons For Not Accepting Acts As A Historical Record

Better Essays

“Consider Paul, and you will see that our being mortal brings us the greatest benefits” (Chrysostom, NCE p216). Mortality means being subject to death, and this is a result of the human race not being perfect; not being consistent. When observing ancient accounts of what occurred, it is necessary to remember the mortality of all people, and the inevitable debates that will arise over discrepancies in different sources citing the same instance. Paul of Tarsus is a man who’s life is highly debated, I, however, would argue that though Paul was once a Jewish leader, he experienced a conversion and helped start the new Jesus movement. He then preached what he believed about Jesus to anyone, despite much controversy. In order to dive into these …show more content…

Another argument for the validity of Acts is that “Luke was inseparable from Paul” (NCE p186 Irenaeus). Many times throughout Acts the author, presumably Luke, says “we”, referring to the fact that he was with Paul throughout the book (the “we” passages in Acts include Acts 16:10-17, 20:5-15, 21:1-18, and 27:1-28:16). Surely if the author was there, it is a reliable view, yet different perspective, of what occurred in Paul’s life. Other important and reliable sources from the Bible are Paul’s epistles. Many say that theses undisputed letters present a seemingly completely different person of Paul than Acts presents, but I am willing to argue that this is simply due to differing perspectives. Two people viewing or living the same thing will almost always result in somewhat different stories. I do not think that there are any contradictions between the two that are big enough to invalidate either of the sources. The final sources I will use are the opinions of both ancient and modern critics, as well as ancient sources. Even Paul’s background and the basis of who he was is heavily debated. According to Acts 22:3, Paul was born in Tarsus, but raised and educated in Jerusalem by the pharisee Gamaliel. As he was raised in the Jewish church, he became a prominent Jewish leader, with his main focus on persecuting those who followed Jesus (Acts 8:1-3,

Get Access