preview

Puerto Rico's Identity Formation Under U.S. Colonial Rule Essay example

Better Essays

Puerto Rico's Identity Formation Under U.S. Colonial Rule

Upon continuing the discussion of what it means to be Puerto Rican, it is clear that the early US colonial rule fundamentally shaped the character of this definition. At the conclusion of the Spanish-American War, Puerto Rico became a possession of the United States subject only to the privileges that the US was willing to grant it. The dichotomy between Puerto Rico’s expectations and what it actually became after 1898, helped to formulate elite definitions of what it meant to be Puerto Rican. This new Puerto Rican identity, which was in large part based upon historical myths, served as defense mechanisms to combat the elite’s dissatisfaction with the new political, social and …show more content…

This US expectation for what Puerto Rico would become after 1898 first manifested itself in the Foraker Act (1900-1917) and later the Jones Act (1917-1950). Although the Jones Act would extend US "citizenship" to the Puerto Ricans whom desired it, it was merely "a form of citizenship without rights" (58). The Puerto Rican Senate and House of Representatives were severely limited by President’s line item veto and the fact that they still remained under the absolute jurisdiction of the Constitution. Such limitations against the Puerto Rican people seemed very reasonable to the US colonizers given the fact that they were faced with the "responsibility" of preparing a politically immature people to someday achieve self government.

This responsibility is portrayed well upon examination of Puerto Rico through the Library of Congress’ photo exhibit entitled "Touring Turn-of-the-Century America Photographs from the Detroit Publishing Company, 1880-1920." The photo entitled "On the Military Road, Puerto Rico" (c. 1903) and "The Military Road, Puerto Rico" (c. 1903) presents a scene in which the US soldiers had to penetrate a dark, thick, and mysterious jungle in order to find Puerto Rican society. In contrast to the depiction of Puerto Rican society several decades after the US occupation, the photo

Get Access