preview

Proximate Cause Of Car Accident

Decent Essays

The diver’s injury from a defective steering wheel meets proximate cause. According to Melvin and Katz (2015), proximate cause is met when a breach of duty occurs in the closest proximity of the incident and without an unforeseen event that cancels out liability. In the case of the accident, proximate cause is met because a motorist being involved in an accident is not an unreasonable occurrence. In addition, the steering wheel manufacturer is held at a strict liability due to the manufacturing of goods for consumers. According to Stewart (2016), a manufacturer is liable for injuries when the product is proven defective and is unreasonably dangerous. For example, in West v. Caterpillar Tractor Co., Inc., West, who was a dealer of Caterpillar’s products, claimed that because manufacturers imply their products are safe, the manufacturer holds the burden of liability. Moreover, the plaintiff must prove the manufacturer’s relationship to the defective product, the dangerous condition, and proximate cause of related injuries. In the case of the driver suing the manufacturer of the steering mechanism, the plaintiff must prove the manufacturer produced the defective mechanism, the reason the mechanism caused the injury, and proximate cause. A likely defense from the manufacturer will be the cause of the motorist’s accident. However, vehicle accidents are not outside the scope of a likely event; therefore, the plaintiff will have a strong case.

Question 2: A tenant hurts herself falling down defective steps. The tenant sues the landlord’s insurance company, alleging that they knew the steps were defective but insured him anyway, thus discouraging him from fixing them.

The tenant’s injury is does not meet proximate cause to the insurance company’s product.
According to Melvin and Katz (2015), proximate cause relates to the nearest breach of duty associated with the harm. In other words, the acts of intervening negligence from the landlord exempts the insurance company’s proximate cause, thus causing liability to fall upon the landlord. Moreover, the property owner’s duties include notifying guests of hazards, duty to inspect, and duty to repair defects. Various state laws require property owners certain

Get Access